Israeli media detail 'Israel’s' failed Iran war objectives
Israeli media examine the outcomes of the war on Iran, arguing that Israeli strategy fell short across political, nuclear, and maritime objectives.
-
US President Donald Trump shakes hands with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during a news conference at Mar-a-Lago, Dec. 29, 2025, in Palm Beach, Fla. (AP)
Amir Oren, a senior correspondent and columnist for Haaretz, argued in a report that "Israel" failed to achieve the objectives of its war on Iran, noting that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “will not pay out of his own pocket for the absolute failure of this war.”
He identified three core dimensions of failure: “the regime that was not toppled, the buried nuclear program that was not dismantled, and the Strait was not opened,” adding that everything else amounts to little more than “stories and excuses.”
In detail, Oren revealed that “they have failed—the regime held on, and the nuclear project still exists (which would not have happened had it not been for Trump’s breach of Barack Obama’s agreement, encouraged by Netanyahu), while the maritime blockade shocked Trump.”
He further explained that the Israeli Air Force’s efforts to degrade Iran’s military capabilities and “push back the starting line of the next round” did not produce meaningful results, since “the objectives of the responsible leadership were not achieved.” He stressed that “victory or defeat are not measured by the number of corpses or destroyed vehicles.”
By contrast, Oren argued that the only absolute truth was “the strike on the home front and the depth,” referring to the Israeli front that Netanyahu, in his view, neglected throughout his tenure while pursuing confrontation with Iran. He also pointed to "Israel’s" broader strategic depth, “stretching from New York to California through the administration, Congress, political parties, and public opinion,” according to Oren.
Between 'assessment' and 'readiness'
In this context, he emphasized that “everything begins and ends with rhetoric,” noting that in analyzing the terminology used during the disastrous failure of the 2026 Iran war, “the air comes out of the balloon of rhetoric inflated by Trump and Netanyahu.”
Oren argued that key strategic terms, misused and conflated by decision-makers and officials in Tel Aviv, including Netanyahu, Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir, senior generals, Mossad chief David Barnea, and also the White House, became conceptual traps. These included “objectives versus tasks, inputs versus outputs, assessment and readiness, surprise and shock, and reasonability versus probability.”
He noted that “a politician or leader may review a set of options, all of them bad and of limited utility, yet still choose one over the status quo,” meaning that the probability of selecting an “unreasonable” option is actually high.
According to Oren, this is precisely what Iran did when it “disrupted the calculations of Trump and Netanyahu,” responding to the attack by striking Gulf states and closing the Strait of Hormuz.
While such actions may appear irrational from a superficial Western perspective, where the likelihood of Iran behaving this way is considered low, it was precisely this move, he argued, that led Trump to retreat.
Closure of the Strait of Hormuz
Oren further noted that the closure of Hormuz was not a “surprise” in the narrow sense, but rather a “shock", since shock occurs when a scenario has been considered but dismissed or marginalized.
He added that closing the Strait “was not an innovative or unexpected move in March 2026,” as it had already been discussed and simulated, including in war games and video simulations.
He then linked “assessment” and “readiness”, arguing that even if the probability of such an action had been considered low before the war, the Pentagon should nevertheless have prepared operational plans to counter or respond to it swiftly.
He explained that “assessment” is only a framework heading under which various layers fall: “enemy assessment, environmental assessment, self-assessment,” culminating in “situational assessment,” which ultimately rests with decision-makers rather than their advisors.
'Trump does not assess but follows his gut instinct'
Regarding Trump, Oren said that the “assessor” does not truly assess but rather “feels", stating that, by Trump’s own descriptions, his “gut instinct and bones” guide his decisions.
“This is his arrogance,” Oren wrote, adding that Trump believes he is always right politically and operationally. When logic becomes a matter of impulse, analysts in Tehran and Tel Aviv struggle to predict how Trump’s instincts translate into decisions and rhetoric.
He concluded that under Trump, “whims prevailed", while under Netanyahu, “the considerations were external, personal, judicial, and political.”