Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
Colombia: President Gustavo Petro: Trump's insult to myself and Colombia is no longer aimed at achieving an effective counter-drug strategy
Trump cancels Putin meeting, says "didn't feel right"
Al Mayadeen's correspondent in Caracas: The United States attacks another alleged drug-trafficking ship off the coast of Colombia in the Pacific Ocean
Palestinian official urges world to force 'Israel' to comply with ICJ ruling: AFP
Israeli media says Knesset approved bill to annex in West Bank in preliminary reading
Kremlin: As part of strategic nuclear force exercise, Cruiser Bryansk launched Sineva ballistic missile from Barents Sea.
Kremlin: Yars Intercontinental Ballistic Missile launched from Plesetsk Cosmodrome at Kura test site in Kamchatka.
Kremlin: Strategic nuclear forces exercise took place under Putin's leadership.
Lebanese MP Imad Al-Hout, following his meeting with the Grand Mufti of the Republic: Lebanon is the last country to move toward peace and normalization [with "Israel"]
Al Mayadeen's correspondent in South Lebanon: One martyr reported in Israeli drone strike targeting motorcycle in Ain Qana.

Moment of truth: Will the US remain committed to Europe’s defense?

  • By Al Mayadeen English
  • Source: The Atlantic
  • 11 Sep 2025 16:58
6 Min Read

Russia's alleged drone strike on Poland sparks a NATO crisis, testing US security guarantees and exposing long-standing tensions in the alliance.

Listen
  • x
  • In this photo taken from video distributed by Russian Defense Ministry Press Service on Wednesday, July 23, 2025, Russian soldiers prepare a Lancet drone for action in an undisclosed location in Ukraine (AP)
    In this photo taken from video distributed by Russian Defense Ministry Press Service on Wednesday, July 23, 2025, Russian soldiers prepare a Lancet drone for action in an undisclosed location in Ukraine (AP)

Earlier this week, Russia’s alleged drone incursion into Poland triggered the long-feared NATO crisis, forcing an immediate test of the United States' commitment to defending its allies. This event shatters the illusion that such a confrontation could be indefinitely postponed, making the world wait to see if American security guarantees still hold.

For years, allies employed a strategy of appeasing Donald Trump, tolerating humiliation and tariffs to avoid this exact scenario. This allowed everyone to maintain the facade of transatlantic unity while delaying the hard choices about European self-reliance, but that strategy has now collapsed with the arrival of a direct attack, Robert Kagan stated in an op-ed for The Atlantic.

From Putin’s perspective, there was every strategic incentive to force a confrontation immediately rather than delay, and the only surprising aspect of his decision to attack Poland is that he had not taken this provocative action sooner, though Russia denies any involvement in sending drones into Polish territory, according to The Atlantic.

Historically, the laws of neutrality considered a nation a belligerent if its government directly provided weapons to a country at war, making it a legitimate target for attack. This framework, which was standard prior to World War II, did not distinguish between aggressor and victim, focusing solely on the act of supplying military aid. Private arms sales were the exception, but government-to-government transfers were a clear violation of neutrality.

Kagan highlighted that from a historical legal perspective, Putin has always had a viable option to attack NATO supply lines into Ukraine. Bombing the routes through Poland, Romania, or Slovakia to cut off the flow of weapons would have been an action within his rights under these traditional rules of war. This longstanding principle is why such an escalation has always been a foreseeable risk.

Only party more afraid of US intervention was US itself

Several factors likely delayed this action, according to Robert Kagan. Initially, Russia's military capacity was limited, as evidenced by its struggles to target Kyiv consistently. However, analysts assess that the primary deterrent was the significant risk of directly engaging NATO and the United States in the conflict, which represented a major strategic concern for Moscow, particularly after its forces failed to secure a quick victory and became entrenched in Ukraine.

A direct NATO entry into the conflict would have been catastrophic for Russian forces, as US capabilities could swiftly sever critical supply lines like the Kursk Bridge, trapping and decimating Moscow's troops. Faced with an unwinnable conventional war, Putin's only alternatives would have been a suicidal nuclear exchange or surrender. Consequently, despite his nuclear posturing, he meticulously avoided actions that would trigger a direct NATO military response.

Related News

Colombian President Petro vows legal action over US drug allegations

Trump cancels Putin meeting, denies US role in Ukraine strikes

From the outset, American officials exhibited a profound fear of direct intervention that often appeared to rival Putin's own. Following the acquisition of detailed intelligence on Russia's plans in late 2021, the Biden administration's response was limited to issuing warnings, threatening sanctions, and sharing intelligence with allies and the media. This pattern of caution, prioritizing deterrence and disclosure over any action that might be seen as escalatory, persisted throughout the subsequent stages of the war.

The Biden administration deliberately avoided any military moves that could be interpreted as a willingness to engage, such as deploying ships to the Black Sea or forward-positioning NATO troops. It carefully refrained from any action that signaled a potential military response to the anticipated invasion. This extreme caution was exercised even with full knowledge that an attack was imminent.

How Russia navigated the beginning of the war

From Putin’s perspective, the signals were likely clear: his initial strategy relied on a rapid victory to present NATO with a fait accompli. However, the United States, despite having detailed knowledge of his plans for months, meticulously avoided any military preparations or threats, indicating that their response would be limited to economic sanctions, a consequence he had already calculated he could endure.

With the operation stalled and nearly 200,000 troops vulnerable in Ukraine, Putin faced a potential defeat; any NATO threat to destroy key infrastructure like the Kursk Bridge would have trapped his forces, leaving him only the catastrophic choice between surrender and an unwinnable global nuclear war, according to The Atlantic. Using tactical nukes in Ukraine would have irradiated his own army while leaving NATO's conventional forces fully intact to finish the job.

And yet, once again, the United States refrained from any direct military engagement, choosing instead to supply Ukraine with weapons that came with significant restrictions on their use, and it deliberately avoided any action that could be perceived as aggressive, thereby allowing Putin to successfully navigate through what was the greatest moment of peril for Russia since the battle of Stalingrad.

After surviving his initial strategic disaster and accurately assessing American reluctance to intervene, Putin logically escalated by pressuring Ukraine's neighbors and supply lines. This move directly exploited the central contradiction in US policy, which aimed to arm Ukraine while avoiding a direct clash with Russia. For years, Putin avoided forcing Washington to choose between these goals, but that calculation has now changed, The Atlantic revealed.

Moving the goalposts

Russia's main goal is to make Ukraine surrender, and the attacks allegedly launched into Poland are meant to create fear and turn Polish people against supporting Ukraine, especially if they start to doubt that the United States will defend them, which could then force Ukrainians to face the reality of fighting without any outside help.

Beyond Ukraine, Putin's broader objective is the dissolution of NATO itself, The Atlantic maitains. He has long pursued a "shadow war" against member states, employing sabotage, arson, and assassination to erode their will to support Kiev.

This strategy aims to make the cost of aiding Ukraine prohibitively high. The US response under Trump, urging European self-reliance, hinting at troop withdrawals, and canceling key defense programs, has inadvertently advanced Putin's goal by signaling American retreat.

The Atlantic concludes that Putin's "shadow war" was a test to gauge US tolerance, and the lack of response encouraged him to escalate into open attacks on Poland. This move directly forces the issue of American commitment into the open. While ignoring strikes in Ukraine was one thing, a failure to respond to an attack on a NATO ally would force Europe to finally accept that US security guarantees are no longer reliable.

  • United States
  • Biden administration
  • Poland
  • Nato
  • Europe
  • Russia
  • Trump administration
  • war in Ukraine
  • Ukraine
  • Vladimir Putin
Russia & NATO

Russia & NATO

As the Draconian Western-led sanctions on Russia exacerbate the economic crisis worldwide, and as Russian troops gain more ground despite the influx of military aid into Ukraine, exposing US direct involvement in bio-labs spread across Eastern Europe and the insurgence of neo-Nazi groups… How will things unfold?

Most Read

Yemeni Armed Forces Chief of Staff Major General Mohammad Abd al-Karim al-Ghamari , during a ceremony in an undisclosed locations in Yemen, undate (Yemeni Military Media)

Yemeni Armed Forces mourn martyred Chief of Staff al-Ghamari

  • Politics
  • 16 Oct 2025
From previous scenes of the Qassam Brigades targeting an Israeli D9 bulldozer with a Yassin 105 shell, east of Deir al-Balah. (Military Media of the Qassam Brigades)

US knew fatal Rafah blast cause was not Hamas op., says journalist

  • Politics
  • 20 Oct 2025
Smoke and fire rises after 'Israel' launched airstrikes on the village of Ansar, Lebanon, October 16, 2025 (social media)

'Israel' launches two waves of brutal strikes on east, south Lebanon

  • Politics
  • 16 Oct 2025
Abu Hamza, the spokesperson for the Al-Quds Brigades, during a speech televised on October 22, 2025 (Al-Quds Brigades Military Media)

Al-Quds Brigades' Abu Hamza mourns leaders, vows continued resistance

  • Politics
  • 22 Oct 2025

Coverage

All
War on Gaza

Read Next

All
Pro-Palestinian activists protest at Lafayette Park across from the White House to mark the approaching one year anniversary of the Israeli war on Gaza, Saturday, October 5, 2024, in Washington. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana)
Arts and Culture

Jewish figures calls for sanctions on 'Israel' over Gaza genocide

Activists from the Foreign Press Association during a panel calling for press freedom in Gaza, April 11, 2025 in London, England. (X/ @FPALondon)
Politics

FPA demands Israeli court to allow int'l journalists access to Gaza

Matsapha Correctional Complex is seen in Matsapha, near Mbabane, Eswatini, Thursday July 17, 2025. (AP Photo)
Politics

Cuban man deported from US to Eswatini launches hunger strike

Russia President Vladimir Putin conducts a strategic nuclear forces exercise via videoconference from the Presidential Situation Centre at the Kremlin in Moscow, on Wednesday, October 22, 2025. (Alexander Kazakov, Sputnik, Kremlin Pool Photo via AP)
Politics

Putin oversees ICBM, cruise missile tests in strategic nuclear drill

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS