Officer exits Australian army after showing more loyalty to 'Israel'
3 Min Read
An Australian army officer quits the military after losing security clearance for saying he'd share classified information with "Israel."
-
People carry flags as members of the Jewish community gather at a park in Sydney, Australia, on Monday, Oct. 7, 2024. (AP Photo/Rick Rycroft)
An Australian army officer has left the Australian Defence Force (ADF) after the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) stripped him of his security clearance, citing concerns over his loyalty to "Israel". The case, first reported by The Guardian, has raised broader questions about foreign influence, undisclosed training, and security integrity within Australia’s military ranks.
The officer, anonymized as "HWMW" in tribunal documents, was removed from active service after the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) upheld ASIO’s findings earlier this year. Initially placed in the inactive reserve, The Guardian reports that he has now formally exited the ADF.
ASIO flagged serious loyalty concerns during interviews, where the officer declared he did not consider "Israel" a foreign government. He also admitted he would share classified Australian military information with the Israeli occupation forces (IOF) if asked.
These revelations led ASIO to conclude that he lacked the "appropriate character and trustworthiness" necessary to hold any security clearance.
Further investigations revealed the officer had failed to disclose participation in training programs conducted in "Israel" in 2016 and 2019. Despite serving 19 years in the ADF, he concealed courses involving self-defense, firearms training, and security techniques.
These sessions were linked to his volunteer role in a Sydney-based Community Security Group (CSG), which provides intelligence and protection services to the Jewish community. He was affiliated with the CSG between 2014 and 2023. When questioned, he claimed the omission was not a lie but “not a complete disclosure.” He further admitted that such CSG programs could serve as “natural recruiting pools” for Mossad, "Israel's" intelligence service.
Political reactions
Greens Senator David Shoebridge, the party’s defence spokesperson, sharply criticized the government’s response. In Senate estimates, Shoebridge questioned whether the defence department had conducted a broader review of ADF personnel with ties to similar CSG training.
He expressed frustration over the lack of answers, stating: “This should have been a simple exercise. Having discovered an ADF member undertook secret training associated with a foreign government, then the exit should have been rapid.” Shoebridge also criticized what he described as Australia’s inconsistent stance on foreign affiliations, pointing to a double standard in the acceptance of loyalty to the US and its allies.
ASIO Director General Mike Burgess emphasized that while community security groups serve a legitimate and important purpose, transparency is key.
“There is nothing wrong with the community security groups,” Burgess said, but noted that foreign training, even for community protection, must be declared. “Training done overseas in Israel might present an opportunity,” he added.
The defense department has reiterated that all holders of security clearances undergo regular evaluations, including reviews of foreign connections and external loyalties. Individuals are required to report any affiliations that might compromise their suitability.
