Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
Israeli media: One Israeli soldier killed in a "security incident" in Khan Younis, south of the Gaza Strip
Israeli media: Intense exchange of fire in Khan Younis
Israeli media platform reports on a tough incident in Gaza still under media censorship
Iran's judiciary says 71 killed in Israeli strike on Evin Prison
Trump: Make the deal, get the hostages back
Al Mayadeen's correspondent: 67 Palestinians were martyred in 24 hours in the Israeli aggression on the Gaza Strip
Israeli media: For the first time, Prime Minister Netanyahu is signaling that he wants to end the war on Gaza
Israeli Channel 12, citing an American source: We want to have entered a path toward captive release and a ceasefire before Netanyahu arrives in Washington
Lebanese Ministry of Health: One martyr and two injured in the Israeli airstrike that targeted a motorcycle in the town of Mahrouna
Al Mayadeen correspondent to Southern Lebanon: An Israeli drone strike targeted a vehicle between the towns of Jwayya and Mahrouna.

Harvard student censored for 'war on Gaza continuation of Nakba'

  • By Al Mayadeen English
  • Source: The Guardian
  • 10 Jun 2024 09:25
  • 4 Shares
5 Min Read

Rabea Eghbariah sees "Israel’s" war on Gaza as part of a continuing Nakba to destroy Palestinian life on land that the occupation wants to fully occupy.

  • x
  • Palestinian human rights lawyer and Harvard Law School student Rabea Eghbariah (Harvard Law_
    Palestinian human rights lawyer and Harvard Law School student Rabea Eghbariah (Harvard Law)

A Monday morning was supposed to be a good day for Palestinian human rights lawyer Rabea Eghbariah after his article went online. “It was supposed to be a very exciting moment,” he remembered. However, shortly after, it became inaccessible and the website was “under maintenance”.

Suddenly, he realizes it's much more than a maintenance bug. “It was very alarming that they would go to that extent,” he said.

His article was censored. But why?

The Harvard Law School doctoral candidate was working for the legal organization Adalah where he has represented Palestinian clients and worked on a landmark case to fight "Israel’s" cyber unit and fought to reunite families separated by "Israel".

“You have an invisible map in your head where you know what laws to invoke depending on the case,” Eghbariah said, “and this is not intuitive at all.”

The Nation has released the article that the Harvard Law Review declined to publish in its entirety.

He explained, “It’s kind of a system of domination by fragmentation,” adding, “We become trained in doing these legal gymnastics, and flipping from one framework to the other, without sometimes even reflecting about the nature of this.”

In a controversial move, the Columbia Law Review's website was taken down entirely following its refusal to delete an article on #Palestine, The Intercept reported on June 3.

Human rights lawyer Rabea Eghbariah's paper, intended for publication in the #Columbia Law Review, was… pic.twitter.com/Ojs6jUmobB

— Al Mayadeen English (@MayadeenEnglish) June 5, 2024

To articulate this, in his piece, he argues that the term Nakba speaks of the layered and overlapping legal entanglements of Palestinian life when self-determination is banned. 

He states that the Nakba of 1948 is not a historical point in time, as he cites his grandparents' survival of the Nakba in his research. He sees "Israel’s" war on Gaza as part of a continuing Nakba to destroy Palestinian life on land that the occupation wants to occupy.

“It’s an organic framework that has been developed in Palestine to reference the ramifications and ongoing nature of the Nakba of 1948,” Eghbariah said, noting, “What the genocide moment and discourse did to that is that it actually made me think about it in legal terms.”

'Provocative' screening

The Guardian explains that US laws are made through scholars revealing out a new approach in a law review and practitioners trying it, which can lead to case law or legislative efforts.

Related News

Putin-Trump meeting in Istanbul requires mutual consent: Kremlin

Islamophobic attacks surge after Mamdani’s historic primary victory

Diala Shamas, an attorney with the Center for Constitutional Rights, told The Guardian, “Those ideas get refined in the process.”

“It’s provocative, and it’s exactly what scholarship should be doing. It’s exactly what Palestinian scholars need to be doing.”

The #Harvard Law Review (HLR) has banned the publication of an article titled: "The Ongoing Nakba: Towards a Legal Framework for Palestine."

Written by #Palestinian human rights lawyer Rabea Eghbariah, a Harvard Law School doctoral candidate, the piece had passed editorial… pic.twitter.com/IKqQ8JSR8m

— Al Mayadeen English (@MayadeenEnglish) November 26, 2023

Student editors at the Columbia Law Review contacted Eghbariah after October 7, given the fact that no Palestinian author had previously written for the journal. 427 footnotes were added to the piece after it went through “at least” five edits from about a dozen editors at the student-run journal.

Despite these efforts, Eghbariah's work was once again suppressed.

Some editors, as per AP, “expressed concerns about threats to their careers and safety if it were to be published,” and when they did publish it, the school board claimed in a statement after restoring the website that it “received multiple credible reports that a secretive process was used to edit” the article, which is why they took it down. 

Jameel Jaffer, director of the Knight First Amendment Institute at the university, stated that “nuking the website is a drastic, extraordinary step that requires much more justification than has been supplied by the directors thus far."

The law school journal’s faculty and alumni board had shuttered the website for most of the week rather than publicize Eghbariah’s 105-page article, titled "Toward the Nakba as a Legal Concept." In his piece, Eghbariah proposed a new framework to explain the complex, fragmented legal regimes governing Palestinians.

He wanted to bring the word Nakba – which translates from Arabic as catastrophe and is better known for describing the expulsion and dispossession of Palestinians in 1948 – to the center of a new legal conversation.

“What is so scary about Palestinians having the right to narrate their own realities?” Eghbariah asks, especially as student-run journals rarely ever hear from boards.

Columbia Law Review Board of Directors has taken down the entire website after @RabeaEghbariah’s article on Nakba went live.

This is the second time Rabea has been censored by a prominent law journal which commissioned his work. @ColumLRev please explain how this is anything… pic.twitter.com/rkkyn9kcaM

— Sarah Schwartz (@Sarah__Schwartz) June 4, 2024

“It’s unprecedented to even interfere in editorial processes,” he said. 

Prominent academic Noah Feldman and author of To Be a Jew Today is one of Eghbariah’s advisors at Harvard Law School, and he called the lawyer “one of the most brilliant students I’ve taught in 20 years as a law professor," asserting that he “certainly” stood by his assessment of Eghbariah’s talents.

With that being said, Eghbariah expresses hope that this debacle will yield more attention to the genocide in Gaza. 

“There is a continuum between the material reality in Gaza and shutting down these debates,” he said. “They’re not separate issues.”

“The attempts to silence legal scholarship on the Nakba by subjecting it to an unusual and discriminatory process are not only reflective of a pervasive and alarming Palestine exception to academic freedom,” Eghbariah said, as quoted by The Intercept last week, “but are also a testament to a deplorable culture of Nakba denialism.”

  • United States
  • Gaza Strip
  • Israel
  • Gaza genocide
  • Nakba
  • Columbia University
  • Gaza
  • Rabea Eghbariah
  • Harvard
War on Gaza

War on Gaza

Most Read

Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian attends a protest following the US attacks on nuclear sites in Iran, in Tehran, Iran, Sunday, June 22, 2025. (AP)

Iran declares victory as ceasefire forces Israeli retreat

  • Politics
  • 24 Jun 2025
Iran launches strikes on Israeli targets, despite alleged ceasefire

Iran victorious as ceasefire with 'Israel' takes effect

  • Politics
  • 24 Jun 2025
The site of a direct missile strike launched from Iran in Tel Aviv on Sunday, June 22, 2025. (AP)

Op. True Promise 3, wave 21: Multi-warhead missiles rain on 'Israel'

  • Politics
  • 23 Jun 2025
Iran says targeted US Qatar air base under Op. Annunciation of Victory

Iran says targeted US Qatar air base under Op. Annunciation of Victory

  • MENA
  • 23 Jun 2025

Coverage

All
The Ummah's Martyrs

Read Next

All
Israeli media: Iran struck sensitive bases; only a fraction revealed
Politics

Only a fraction of Iranian missiles impact revealed: Israeli media

Pro-Palestinian protest in Sydney ends in crackdown, serious injury
Politics

Pro-Palestine Sydney protest ends in violent crackdown, serious injury

Israeli soldiers
Palestine

IOF soldiers blame army for negligence after deadly Khan Younis ambush

Corsican Assembly recognizes Palestine, condemns Israeli genocide
Politics

Corsican Assembly recognizes Palestine, condemns Israeli genocide

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS