Russia challenges Germany's Nord Stream sabotage investigation
Moscow says Germany's refusal to cooperate with Russian investigators undermines confidence in the Nord Stream case, as a Hamburg trial examines alleged Ukrainian involvement and debate over the pipeline's future continues.
-
In this picture provided by the Swedish Coast Guard, a leak from Nord Stream 2 is seen on Sept. 28, 2022. (Swedish Coast Guard via AP)
Russia has challenged the credibility of Germany's investigation into the 2022 Nord Stream pipeline explosions, accusing Berlin of refusing to cooperate with Moscow and questioning whether the German judicial process can be considered impartial.
Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Dmitry Lyubinsky told Izvestia that German authorities had avoided engaging with Russia throughout the four years since the explosions. He said this contradicted Germany's international obligations to provide legal assistance in criminal investigations and comply with counterterrorism agreements.
Lyubinsky also recalled that Russia and other countries had proposed an independent international investigation under United Nations auspices, but the initiative was rejected.
"Under these circumstances, it becomes extremely difficult to speak about the impartiality of the German judicial authorities or the credibility of the findings of their investigation," he said.
Read more: Nord Stream sabotage probe fractures European unity over Ukraine: WSJ
Hamburg trial raises further questions
The criticism comes as proceedings over the September 2022 explosions continue in Hamburg. According to Izvestia, the trial began on October 14, with witnesses at the latest hearing reporting that a woman was among the suspected group. Images of forged Ukrainian passports allegedly used by the suspects to enter the European Union were also presented in court.
German investigators have identified two Ukrainian nationals, Serhii Kuznetsov and Volodymyr Zhuravlyov, as the main suspects in the Nord Stream 2 sabotage. Investigators say Kuznetsov, a former Ukrainian special forces officer, led the group.
Izvestia noted that the findings had not prompted Berlin to take action against Kiev.
Russia's Federal Security Service opened a criminal case in 2022 on charges of international terrorism and sought legal assistance from Germany, Denmark, Sweden, and Switzerland. According to the newspaper, all four countries except Germany subsequently closed their investigations.
Russian Foreign Ministry spokesperson Maria Zakharova also accused the Higher Regional Court in Hamburg of preventing Nord Stream operators from participating in the trial. She said the court had yet to address what she described as evidence presented by Germany's Federal Public Prosecutor General that a suspect had acted on instructions from Ukrainian authorities.
AfD calls for investigation into Kiev's role
The case has also become a subject of political debate in Germany. Bundestag member Steffen Kotré of the Alternative for Germany (AfD) told Izvestia that his party had submitted 300 inquiries to the federal government concerning the explosions.
Kotré called for investigators to establish whether the Ukrainian state was involved, arguing that identifying the alleged direct perpetrators was not sufficient to determine responsibility.
He also demanded clarification of the United States' role, citing American journalist Seymour Hersh's 2023 investigation, which accused Washington of involvement in the sabotage.
Separately, Izvestia, citing Reuters, reported that senior Russian and US officials discussed in October the possibility of attracting an American investor to Nord Stream projects.
The newspaper also reported on a proposal by Russian presidential envoy Kirill Dmitriev to hold a Russian-German-American business forum in 2027. Dmitriev said the idea had received support from the US Chamber of Commerce and the AfD. Kotré said party representatives would discuss the proposal with him in December, while Italian business representatives expressed interest in participating if invited.
Moscow signals readiness to resume gas supplies
The dispute over the pipeline investigation comes amid renewed discussion of restoring Russian gas deliveries to Europe.
Russian Deputy Prime Minister Alexander Novak said Europe would eventually need gas through Nord Stream, noting that one of the pipelines remained intact and that Moscow was prepared to resume supplies immediately. President Vladimir Putin expressed the same readiness at the St. Petersburg International Economic Forum in June.
Lyubinsky said, however, that resuming deliveries would require political will and commitment from German authorities, adding that he had seen no indication of either.
Germany's gas storage facilities were 61% full on November 1, below the target level of 70%, according to the Association of Underground Gas Storage Operators. Izvestia reported that withdrawal rates had exceeded three times the average for the previous five years.
The newspaper also placed German gas prices at 850–870 euros per 1,000 cubic meters, more than 2.6 times their level a year earlier. It said higher energy costs were weighing on major industrial and chemical companies, particularly those dependent on short-term energy contracts.
Citing Bloomberg, Izvestia further reported that around 190,000 German companies ceased operations in 2025, nearly 10% more than the previous year and the highest number in more than a decade.
AfD co-leader Alice Weidel renewed her call for the resumption of Russian gas supplies in September. However, Artem Sokolov, a researcher at the Moscow State Institute of International Relations, said the party's participation in a federal government remained difficult to envisage and that its position on Russian gas had not gained support from state institutions.
Izvestia argued that rising energy costs were strengthening calls for dialogue between European businesses and individual EU member states, despite the European Union's continued efforts to phase out Russian energy sources. It suggested that restoring some supplies and reviewing energy sanctions could contribute to an economic settlement if negotiations over a new European security architecture were launched.
Read more: Finland urges Europe to hold direct talks with Putin