Sanctions losing impact? EU measures barely dent Russia: Analysis
Hungary vetoes EU sanctions on Russia, exposing tensions between European energy dependence, domestic politics, and Ukraine war strategy.
-
Hungary's Prime Minister Viktor Orban addresses a media conference at the end of a European Union summit in Brussels, on December 19, 2024. (AP)
Hungary’s veto of the European Union’s 20th sanctions package against Russia has reignited debate over the effectiveness of Europe’s economic measures and the trajectory of the war in Ukraine, Ian Proud, a former British diplomat, writes for Responsible Statecraft.
The decision, made during an EU Council meeting on February 23, prevented member states from reaching a consensus on new restrictions. EU High Representative for Foreign Policy and Security Kaja Kallas expressed regret over the impasse, noting the timing coincided with the war’s anniversary.
Energy dependence shapes Budapest’s position
Hungary’s resistance reflects a deeper conflict between domestic economic priorities and EU foreign policy. Despite repeated calls to end Russian energy imports, Europe remains reliant on Russian oil and gas. As of October 2025, gas imports accounted for 12% of Europe’s total, with Hungary and Slovakia among the largest importers.
Gladden Pappin, president of the Hungarian Institute for International Affairs, explained the domestic pressures driving Budapest’s stance. For Hungary, sanctioning Russian oil would double gas prices at the pump, triple household energy costs, and halt industrial migration from Germany, potentially destabilizing the government. Germany has already experienced economic contraction, widespread factory closures, and the loss of over 250,000 industrial jobs due to energy cuts.
Domestic politics and the April 12 election
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban has framed the upcoming election as a choice between “war or peace”, emphasizing the growing European desire for de-escalation. Four years into the war, many Europeans are increasingly motivated by economic and personal security concerns, even as Kiev frames the conflict as existential.
Ukraine has pushed European states to adopt tougher sanctions and has undertaken direct actions, such as drone attacks on the Druzhba pipeline network on January 27, which supplies oil to Hungary and Slovakia. These attacks have escalated tensions between Keiv and EU members, with Hungary and Slovakia retaliating by blocking the 20th sanctions package and delaying a €90 billion loan to Ukraine.
Critics, including Polish Foreign Minister Radek Sikorski, labeled Hungary’s veto an “escalation”.
Proud, in his analysis for Responsible Statecraft, emphasizes the limited effect of repeated sanctions. While Europe claims to have reduced Russian energy exports, total exports in 2025 reached $419.4 billion, down just 3.3% from 2024, with a current account surplus of $41.4 billion largely invested in gold reserves. In contrast, Ukraine’s current account deficit more than doubled to $31.9 billion, heightening reliance on European financial aid.
Proud notes that further sanctions risk prolonging the conflict rather than compelling Moscow to negotiate, and argues that strategic use of sanctions, including phased removal, could serve as leverage for a negotiated peace, rather than punishing European citizens or member states prioritizing domestic stability.
Read more: Russia able to sustain Ukraine war through 2026: IISS