Trump is a 'hostage' and 'slave' to 'Israel', Tucker Carlson tells NYT
Tucker Carlson details the US-'Israel' relationship, Trump's capitulation to Netanyahu, and the consequences of the war on Iran.
-
Tucker Carlson attends a meeting with President Donald Trump and oil executives in the East Room of the White House, Friday, Jan. 9, 2026, in Washington. (AP)
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and many of his supporters in the United States are holding President Donald Trump "hostage", American media figure Tucker Carlson said in a recent confrontational interview with the New York Times.
Carlson, who has recently spoken out against the Zionist lobby in Washington, particularly after the aggression on Iran was launched jointly by the United States and "Israel", said that Trump appears to be a "hostage" and "slave" to foreign powers, not only because he started the February 28 war on Iran, but "because he couldn’t get out of it."
⭕️ Tucker Carlson tells The New York Times why he calls U.S. President Donald Trump a “hostage” to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu:
— Drop Site (@DropSiteNews) May 2, 2026
“Trump said, ‘I want a negotiated settlement [with Iran].’ Israel stopped the settlement.”
He explained that the U.S.-Iran ceasefire… pic.twitter.com/zwZo9cmLzh
'Israel' derailing talks to steal more lands
He says Trump has spoken of a ceasefire, which Iran conditioned to "Israel's" withdrawal from Lebanon. Instead, "Israel" used the war on Iran as a pretext "for stealing more land from a sovereign country that’s not your country."
"I thought we were fighting the great existential threat, Iran. And now you’re taking the opportunity to take Lebanon’s shore, the Litani River, and bombing downtown Beirut. What is this?" he told the Times.
Additionally, he recalls the Israeli bombardment of Lebanon and the massacres of civilians, which came only hours after Trump's announcement of a ceasefire, saying this was not to protect "Israel", but to sabotage any potential settlement and resume the aggression "until Iran was destroyed."
Carslon particularly points to the timing of the Israeli aggression, saying "Israel" had done a lot against Lebanon since October 7, including assassinating Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, but chose the moment Trump announced a ceasefire to "derail the negotiations. And they’ve done this repeatedly."
Partnership or subjugation?
Carlson also highlighted that the United States and "Israel" are not co-equals in any sense, but that "Israel" depends on the US fully. "Israel can’t defend itself without the United States, despite whatever propaganda you may have heard," he said, further criticizing US leadership, not "Israel", for not constraining the occupation.
"Trump could not restrain Netanyahu," he said, adding that Netanyahu is the only person Trump could not threaten with detrimental consequences should he refuse a settlement with Iran.
He also noted that Trump could not even criticize Netanyahu for obstructing the ceasefire with Iran. "That’s slavery. That is total control of one man by another," he scoffed, expressing frustration with the American president, who has, so far, placed "Israel" first.
Carlson also dismissed any presumptuous claims of "antisemitism" that he might get for speaking out against Netanyahu and how Trump is capitulating to "Israel". "That’s outrageous. And no amount of 'Oh, you’re an antisemite,' which I’m not, and I’m never going to be, is going to stop me from noting that that’s outrageous. It is outrageous."
On the extensive Israeli control of US leadership
The American journalist further described the extensive control "Israel" has over US presidents when asked, citing the Iraq war as an example, clarifying that former VP Dick Cheney's office was full of people who put "Israel's" interests above America's.
Trump, to Carlson, is no different, particularly during the war on Iran. He recognized Trump's vulnerabilities, but simultaneously stated that weakness was not his perception of the President.
"What was it about this moment that allowed a foreign leader to have this level of influence over an American leader?" he asked, before later saying that launching the joint war on Iran was the "single most foolish thing any American president has ever done."
US economy actively destroyed by Israeli war
When asked why he was so eager to delve into this situation and answer all those questions, Carlson said it was primarily the destruction of the US economy and the killings of US personnel during the war on Iran that "Israel" pushed onto Trump.
"Israel has that power in our Congress," he said, not because there was an abundance of Jews in Congress or the US, but because there is an abundance of Evangelical Jews who irrevocably support "Israel".
He dismissed accusations of him being "obsessed with Israel," stressing that the most important issue is the future of the US economy and the lives of US servicemembers. "I find Israel actually geo-strategically irrelevant except to the extent that we imbue it with relevance at the behest largely of evangelical Christians," he added.
Tucker Carlson just sat with the New York Times for two hours of deranged rambling.Once a voice, now Candace Owens 2.0 pic.twitter.com/AEmELvjCV0
— MAG🔫1775🇺🇸 (@realMAG1775) May 3, 2026
The Vance vs. Rubio conspiracy
On the domestic political front, when asked whether Vice President JD Vance’s current role would affect his political future, Carlson revealed that there are "people in the White House who want to hurt JD Vance and have wanted that since the very first day."
He further noted that said individuals supported Marco Rubio for the Vice President position, which consequently subjected Vance to "nonstop treachery from people on the neoconservative side."
In context
The interview comes at a time of heightened tension within American conservative politics, where support for “Israel” has become an increasingly contentious issue.
Tucker Carlson is an American conservative commentator who has increasingly positioned himself as a critic of US policy toward “Israel” and of Christian Zionism.
While many figures on the American right strongly support “Israel”, often influenced by Christian Zionist beliefs that tie its support to religious doctrine, Carlson has challenged this alignment, questioning the extent of US political and military backing and the role of evangelical influence in shaping it.
In that sense, he stands somewhat apart from traditional pro-“Israel” conservative circles, framing his position as skepticism toward foreign entanglements and the domestic forces that sustain them.
Read more: Trump claims war on Iran could end 'soon', 'Israel' seeks continuation