Trump's strongman strategy risks destabilizing West Asia: FP
Renad Mansour argues that the Trump administration’s reliance on centralized leaders in Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon to curb Iranian influence and advance US interests risks deepening instability.
-
US President Donald Trump meets Lebanese President Joseph Aoun at the White House, as Washington increasingly backs centralized leaders in Lebanon, Syria and Iraq to advance its regional agenda (AFP)
The administration of US President Donald Trump is increasingly relying on handpicked leaders in Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon to centralize political and military authority, restrict Iran’s regional influence, and expand economic cooperation with Washington.
Writing in Foreign Policy, researcher Renad Mansour argued that the emerging policy reflects a departure from previous US support for power-sharing arrangements, federal structures, and negotiated political settlements.
Instead, Washington is placing its confidence in individual leaders it believes can control state institutions, consolidate armed forces, and rapidly implement US priorities.
The approach has been promoted principally by Trump’s envoy and longtime associate Tom Barrack, who has backed stronger central governments in Damascus, Beirut, and Baghdad.
However, Mansour warned that the strategy overlooks the political fragmentation, communal tensions, and competing centers of military power that characterize all three countries.
Washington seeks dependable regional partners
Mansour pointed to Trump’s July meeting with Iraqi Prime Minister Ali al-Zaidi at the White House as a public demonstration of the administration’s approach.
The US president said he shared “tremendous chemistry” with al-Zaidi and suggested that the Iraqi leader was “good for America.” Trump twice predicted that al-Zaidi would remain in power “for a long time.”
The meeting followed Trump’s earlier engagement with Syrian interim President Ahmad al-Sharaa, whom he praised for allegedly bringing together a country that had been “a very disjointed place.”
Trump said al-Sharaa had “unified the country in a very short period of time,” describing him as “a strong person” and “a great leader.”
Mansour also identified Lebanese President Joseph Aoun as another leader incorporated into Washington’s regional calculations. During Aoun’s White House visit, the first by a Lebanese president in more than 15 years, Trump told him, “You have tremendous spirit on your side.”
Personal ties advance US interests
According to Mansour, Washington sees centralized leadership as an efficient means of advancing its interests without committing large numbers of US troops or becoming deeply involved in lengthy political negotiations.
The administration expects its partners to weaken the Axis of Resistance, oversee security institutions, conclude economic agreements with American companies, and pursue arrangements with “Israel".
Under such a model, Mansour wrote, personal relationships become more important than political institutions, with leaders judged primarily by what they can deliver to Washington.
Syria emerges as model for centralization
Mansour described Syria as the clearest example of the administration’s policy.
According to his analysis, al-Sharaa has undergone a significant political rehabilitation since the period when the United States offered a $10 million reward for information leading to his capture.
Trump announced in Saudi Arabia in May 2025 that Washington would lift sanctions imposed during the rule of former Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. US authorities later removed terrorist designations placed on al-Sharaa before his visit to Washington.
Al-Sharaa reportedly sought to appeal to Trump by discussing possible US access to Syrian oil and gas, improved relations with “Israel”, and even the construction of a Trump Tower in Damascus.
Barrack rejects federalism
Barrack has meanwhile rejected proposals to preserve autonomous or federal structures for Syria’s different communities.
“We all need to reconcile and come to this conclusion: one nation, one people, one army, one Syria,” Barrack said in July 2025, adding that “federalism does not work” in the region.
According to Mansour, the envoy has taken a similar position toward the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces, despite their previous cooperation with Washington against ISIS.
“We don’t owe them the ability to have their own independent government within a government,” Barrack said, later claiming that their political function had “largely expired".
Al-Sharaa sets limits
Mansour noted, however, that al-Sharaa’s consolidation efforts primarily serve his own political ambitions and do not necessarily mean that Damascus will follow every US demand.
The Syrian president has opposed suggestions that his forces should confront Hezbollah inside Lebanon and has rejected concessions concerning the occupied Syrian Golan Heights.
Mansour, therefore, argued that al-Sharaa is using US support to strengthen his authority while retaining the ability to reject policies that could threaten his position.
US pressure targets Hezbollah and Iraqi Resistance factions
In Lebanon, Mansour wrote, Washington sees Aoun and the Lebanese Armed Forces as instruments for eliminating Hezbollah’s independent military capabilities.
Aoun, a former army commander, entered office in January 2025 and identified the state’s monopoly over weapons as a central objective.
The Lebanese government subsequently committed itself to addressing groups possessing heavy weapons and assigned the army responsibility for expanding state control.
Washington has paired its disarmament demands with promises of support for reconstruction and economic recovery, while also pressing Beirut toward negotiations with “Israel".
Israeli attacks complicate disarmament
The analysis warned that these demands are being made as Israeli occupation forces continue to attack Lebanon and occupy positions in the country’s South.
Hezbollah has rejected calls to surrender its weapons, while the Lebanese Army has acknowledged that it lacks the capacity to carry out an immediate nationwide disarmament campaign.
Aoun has also resisted Washington’s attempts to impose a rapid timetable. After Barrack warned that Lebanon could cease to exist as a state unless it moved against Hezbollah, Aoun insisted that the process would proceed according to the army’s assessment rather than US demands.
Washington leverages Iraqi revenues
In Iraq, the Trump administration used political and economic pressure to block the return of former Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, whom Washington considers too close to Tehran.
The United States possesses significant leverage because Iraqi oil revenues are held through an account at the US Federal Reserve. Restrictions on Baghdad’s access to those funds placed pressure on Iraq’s political establishment to select a candidate acceptable to Washington.
The eventual choice was al-Zaidi, a 40-year-old banker who lacked a political constituency or previous government experience.
According to the analysis, Iraqi political factions viewed al-Zaidi as a compromise figure, while Washington promoted him as a new leader capable of confronting corruption and absorbing Resistance factions into the official security structure.
Trump later claimed that al-Zaidi had “won the election very soundly,” despite the fact that he had not stood as a candidate.
Political realities undermine US expectations
Mansour argued that Washington’s strategy repeats earlier efforts to impose centralized rule on countries whose political systems are deliberately dispersed.
Iraq’s post-2003 political structure was designed to prevent the emergence of another ruler capable of monopolizing the state, while Lebanon’s confessional system distributes authority among different religious communities.
Syria’s new government also faces armed factions, regional divisions, and communities that remain deeply suspicious of central authority.
Armed factions retain autonomy
In Iraq, several armed groups have indicated a willingness to discuss placing their weapons under government supervision. More strongly aligned Resistance factions, including Kataib Hezbollah and Harakat al-Nujaba, have refused.
In Syria, al-Sharaa’s forces have faced armed resistance and accusations of abuses, particularly following massacres in the Druze-majority province of Sweida.
Mansour further argued that Israeli support for some Druze armed groups has weakened Damascus’ attempts to unify military power under the state.
Pressure risks renewed conflict
Mansour described Lebanon as an even more dangerous case, arguing that an attempt to forcibly disarm Hezbollah while Israeli forces continue their attacks and occupation could deepen sectarian tensions.
The writer said the Lebanese state’s inability to protect southern communities may also reinforce Hezbollah’s argument that its weapons remain necessary for national defense.
Mansour concluded that the Trump administration is prioritizing immediate and highly visible political gains over the slow process of building stable institutions and negotiated settlements.
According to his assessment, efforts to transform Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon according to Washington’s timetable could provoke renewed conflict, weaken central governments, and undermine the very US interests the strategy is intended to protect.
Read more: Trump hosts Aoun, floats Syrian role in fighting Hezbollah