Trump-Zelensky rift nears breaking point, NYT analysis says
Zelensky suggests he is Trump’s scapegoat as Starshield limits, missile warnings and Patriot supplies put Ukraine’s US support at risk, an NYT analysis says.
-
President Donald Trump meets with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy during the United Nations General Assembly, Tuesday, Sept. 22, 2026, at the UN headquarters. (AP)
The relationship between US President Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky appears to be nearing a breaking point after a week in which Washington’s pressure on Kiev spilled into open public confrontation, just ahead of the US midterm elections.
For months, Zelensky had preserved US backing by joining US-led peace talks that yielded little and by flattering Trump’s leadership, according to an analysis by The New York Times (NYT).
The paper argued that this strategy has run its course as the midterms, widely viewed as a referendum on Trump’s presidency, approach.
Their ties have been rocky since Trump took office, the paper recalled, citing his declaration that the era of isolating Russia was over and a tense White House meeting with Zelensky.
Fuel prices at the center of the dispute
Trump blamed the war in Ukraine for rising diesel prices, although energy experts cited by NYT traced the increase to the US war on Iran. He then temporarily lifted US sanctions on Russian diesel sales and unilaterally declared an energy ceasefire, steps the paper judged to have helped Russia and hurt Ukraine.
He also went as far as calling for a new Ukrainian president, a demand echoed by Elon Musk, the chief executive of SpaceX. Trump later told Newsmax that Zelensky was not a good partner for Washington to work with
Zelensky pushes back
Zelensky, after initially holding back, said he felt betrayed and announced that Ukraine would resume strikes on Russian oil refineries despite the declared ceasefire, according to NYT. Later, when asked by journalist Piers Morgan whether Ukraine was losing the United States as an ally, he answered yes.
On Friday in Belgium, Zelensky went further and suggested he is being used as a scapegoat for Trump’s problems, the paper reported.
Washington's leverage over Kiev
Ukraine still relies on the United States for Starshield satellite internet along the front line, intelligence on incoming missiles and targeting support, and Patriot interceptors, the only weapon it can use against Russian ballistic missiles, NYT noted.
Patriot supplies are already stretched worldwide, largely because of the US war on Iran, although Ukraine still receives a small number each month. Losing that help would hurt the Ukrainian military while it has been "performing well" on the front line and put cities under constant missile and drone attack at greater risk, analysts told NYT.
This week gave Kiev a preview of what a loss of that support could look like. Ukrainian soldiers said unexplained Starshield restrictions disrupted drone launches and other operations, Musk suggested that only the US military and ultimately Trump could limit access, and a bipartisan group of US senators has demanded an investigation.
Ukrainian officials separately said they received no advance warning from partners, which NYT said was code for the United States, before two missile waves hit Kiev on Tuesday and Wednesday. The paper said the reason remains unclear and noted that the S-400 missiles involved leave little warning time, while officials said they were alerted to other ballistic attacks.
Limits to Trump’s leverage
However, analysts cited by NYT disagreed on how far that pressure can reach. Washington’s leverage is limited because the United States already stopped donating weapons and Ukraine has expanded its own defense production, argued Nico Lange, a former German defense ministry official now at the Munich Security Conference, who added that Ukraine would not lose the war without American help.
Europe, he acknowledged, cannot fully replace US early-warning intelligence, a gap that would leave civilians unable to reach shelters in time, according to Ukrainian military analyst Oleh Katkov.
Ukraine will keep fighting and rejects talk of "peace" or "capitulation," said Solomiia Bobrovska, a member of parliament’s defense committee, who urged Kiev and its allies to find alternatives to US assistance.
The standoff is "lose-lose" for Trump, Zelensky and Europe, said Balazs Jarabik, a former European Union diplomat in Kiev now at R. Politik.
The worst case for Ukraine would be a suspension of aid by Trump and the Defense Department, an outcome Kiev hopes would prove too politically costly given criticism from some in Trump’s own party, NYT said.
Trump is trying to show he is lowering gas prices while answering those critics, said Harry Nedelcu of Rasmussen Global, who called the episode a geopolitical betrayal. The next couple of weeks could show which way the relationship goes, according to analysts.