No matter the election results, Netanyahu’s two decades in office indict all of 'Israel'
Samuel Geddes argues that Netanyahu’s aggression was not just one man’s strategy, but a project enabled by Israel’s political establishment and public support.
-
Can Netanyahu’s departure really absolve "Israel" of responsibility for years of war and destruction? (Illustrated by Ali Al-Hadi Shmeiss for Al Mayadeen English)
The Jewish extremists in control of “Israel” no longer make much attempt to hide their intentions to build a "Third Temple" in place of the Al-Aqsa Mosque and Dome of the Rock. Were they to succeed in doing so, one of the rituals they would purportedly revive involves the ritual transfer of the Israelites’ collective sins onto two goats – one to be sacrificed and the other cast into the wilderness. This rite is the origin of the term “scapegoating” – making someone else carry the consequences for the deeds of others.
In the lead-up to “Israel’s” 2026 general election this week, a more abstract version of this practice is being wheeled out in the expectation, correctly or not, that Benjamin Netanyahu’s nearly twenty years as Prime Minister are about to come to an end.
According to the likes of former PM Ehud Olmert, responsibility for the atrocities carried out by the Israeli regime lies with Netanyahu, Smotrich, and Ben-Gvir, whose putative removal from office will allow “Israel” to become a “normal” entity again, with the past two decades having been a mere aberration.
If we believe this reasoning, “Israel’s” reputation can, to some degree, be “reset” by a new government, assuming that Netanyahu’s career ends in the coming weeks.
This attempt to pin the horrors of the last three years on the Prime Minister immediately discredits itself, however, when the commissioning of his regional aggressions and atrocities is what has repeatedly saved his government right up until this point.
It has been a truism of Israeli politics that governments almost never reach the end of their natural term. The overwhelming rule is that coalition fractures or internal scandal lead to government collapse well before their mandated end, so that most elections occur “early”.
Somehow the term of Netanyahu’s outgoing government managed to exempt itself from this rule, as the PM usually manages to exempt himself from the legal requirements that even he is theoretically bound by.
Since the October 7 operation of 2023, the PM’s coalition government has been “on the brink” of collapse, its survival ensured only by its coalition partners, the Ultra-Orthodox parties and the extreme Jewish settler parties of Smotrich and Ben-Gvir.
It has long since been established, to anyone paying the slightest attention, that the shape and sequence of “Israel’s” escalating regional aggressions - from the destruction of Gaza to both attacks against Iran - have been Netanyahu’s cynical strategy to prevent the collapse of his government, delaying public accountability for his security failures, and the resumption of his multiple corruption trials.
Every additional front he has opened, from Lebanon to Syria, Yemen, and back to Gaza, has been about running down the clock as long as possible to October 27, 2026, the last mandated date upon which an election can legally be held.
Netanyahu’s frantic rampage across the region, including his trapping the world in an existential economic crisis, was not simply his doing, but was enabled by the entire Israeli political class despite being fully aware of the depth of cynicism driving the PMs’ actions. The damning truth of how this has been allowed is that these are wars that the Israeli society overwhelmingly supports.
Despite the attempts of “Liberal Zionist” ideologues to manufacture a distinction between Netanyahu and the Israeli public that latter overwhelmingly supports the genocide in the Gaza Strip, supports the forced expulsion of the Palestinian population, the proportion believing that “too much” force has been used has never exceeded the single digits.
Whenever the PM has pivoted to reopening a front, particularly against Hezbollah in Lebanon and Iran, he has furiously sabotaged efforts to contain the situation through a ceasefire- despite his failures- precisely because the Israeli public overwhelmingly supports continuous, maximal aggression against every opponent no matter the costs to the settler project itself.
If Israeli public opposition to the regime’s actions were a reality, this government would have long since fallen and the PM’s reign of chaos would have ended. The very fact that the world is holding its breath waiting for Netanyahu to reignite the war with Iran to disrupt or delay the elections demonstrates that these acts are his electoral selling points to the average Israeli voter. He would not be contemplating any of this, let alone spending the last three years doing it, were he not totally assured of near-unanimous public support for his actions.
The simple fact is, if it comes to pass that the Netanyahu era is over, it will be due to nothing more than a slight majority of Israelis’ personal hatred for him, for his personal corruption, his pathological dishonesty, his craven loyalty to nothing but his own interests.
That in no way should be spun as any vindication of Israeli society – Netanyahu is a historically easy person to hate – instead the appropriate question would be why it has taken so long, at the cost of such destruction and death for “Israel” to stop rewarding one man’s lies, atrocities, and corruption as if these were virtues?
Samuel Geddes