'Wow, you're a Hasbara hero!': The 'state'-linked tool that scripted replies to chosen X posts
The posts they praised were picked for them, the posts they reported were picked for them, the words were written for them, and from December 2023, the clicking could be done for them too.
-
How an Israeli-linked online operation coordinated pro-"Israel" messaging (Illustrated by Fatima Attieh for Al Mayadeen English)
Archived copies of the Words of Iron website show the two jobs it gave its volunteers. It told them which posts to boost and handed them 13 stock replies to post: under one post by the head of the Combat Antisemitism Movement, at least 63 of those replies appeared. It also fed them a list of more than 200 posts to report to the platforms as hate speech, from journalists, academics, and Palestinian voices.
On November 7, 2023, Sacha Roytman, chief executive of the Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM), posted a short video on X with the words: "You can't erase the truth." Over the next fortnight, the same few sentences filled the replies. "Anyone who cherishes life must stand shoulder to shoulder with Israel." "Hamas must go - for Israel AND for Gaza!" Each ended with the same tags: #bringthemhome #wordsofiron.
Roytman knows this terrain. As Lieutenant Sacha Dratwa, he headed the new media desk of the Israeli army Spokesperson's Unit, and Reuters described him in 2012 as the officer who "led the army's social media campaign" during that November's assault on Gaza. During "Operation Cast Lead" in 2008–09, as a student at IDC Herzliya, he headed the French-language online monitoring for HelpUsWin.org, a pro-"Israel" "situation room" sponsored by StandWithUs. The post the tool chose belonged to the former head of the army's own social media operation.
The sentences under it were not the posters' own. They came from Words of Iron, a website launched in the first days of the genocide in Gaza to help volunteers boost pro-"Israel" posts and mass-report critical ones. Copies held by the Wayback Machine show both halves of the operation: the feeds that told users which posts to praise and which to report, and the code that gave them the words and the steps.
Who built it
The Israeli tech site Ctech reported on October 12, 2023, that the software engineer Shaked Lokits had set up Words of Iron within two days of October 7. It said the tool was "one of several projects in a joint initiative between the National Information Directorate, the Ministry for Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism, other government offices and tech companies called 'IsraelTechGuards'."
A month later, Ctech reported that a team from the start-up Akooda, led by its chief technology officer Itamar Niddam, had built the system. Niddam said it took in posts "from various sources (including Israeli official entities)" and "even produces pro-Israel content for them using AI."
The Atlantic Council's Digital Forensic Research Lab (DFRLab) later found that the tool had been created by Israel Tech Guard, a volunteer group formed after October 7 whose archived website said it was "working in close cooperation with the IDF and security services." It counted more than 40,000 uses of #wordsofiron by more than 5,000 accounts between October 2023 and March 2024. The Diaspora Ministry still lists Words of Iron first in its Iron Web directory of advocacy tools, as "a platform enabling the reporting of antisemitic content and the boosting of pro-Israeli posts with a single click."
Thirteen sentences
The earliest version of the site, archived on October 12, 2023, called itself an "automation system for Israel supportive content publishing." The script behind its reply page, archived on November 14, 2023, holds a fixed list of 13 replies. The tool picked one, added "#bringthemhome #wordsofiron," and opened X's reply box with the text filled in, ready to post.
The list runs from: "Thank you for standing with Israel 🇮🇱" to "If it looks like ISIS, murders like ISIS and beheads like ISIS, it's ISIS. #HamasisISIS." The first item was "Please pray for the 241 hostages! #BringThemHomeNow"; in the version archived on November 2, it read "203 hostages". The same 13 sentences were still in place in February 2024.
By December 2023, the site offered an "Auto Pilot" button and an "Automat Mode" screen: "All you have to do is take a break and relax - We will do it for you :)." Users ticked "like", "comment" and "save", then pressed "2... 3... La-unch". The progress messages ended: "Wow, you're a Hasbara hero!" By February 2024, the page told users: "First, install our plugin" and linked to a Chrome extension listed as "words-of-iron-automation".
The other half: Mass reporting
Boosting was only one job. From its early weeks, the site urged users to "oin the fight by reporting anti-Israel posts" and to "Help prevent the spread of false or anti-Israeli content by reporting it." It then walked them through each platform's complaint form. On X: "Click 'Report post'", then "Select 'Violent & hateful entities' as type of issue." On Instagram: "Select 'Hate speech or symbols' as type of issue and click 'Submit report'." Facebook and TikTok had their own tutorials. When one report was done, a button offered the next: "New post to report." The same instructions were still there in February 2024.
The site also kept a separate feed of posts to report. Three copies of the X version survive, captured on November 2, 2023, November 14, 2023, and July 30, 2024. Between them, they list 220 different posts, dated from October 24, 2023, to January 15, 2024, by more than 110 accounts. They include posts by the scholar Norman Finkelstein, the journalists Caitlin Johnstone and Richard Medhurst, the commentator Jackson Hinkle (14 posts), alongside dozens of other accounts, many of them Palestinian.
The test the site set was "false OR anti-Israeli", not "false AND anti-Israeli", as Alex Skopic pointed out in Current Affairs in April 2024. Among the posts singled out was a video in which the journalist Owen Jones argued that "Israel's" repeated attacks on Palestinian civilians met the dictionary definition of "terrorism". Users were told to report such posts as "Hate speech or symbols."
A listing shows that the tool asked its users to report a post. It does not show how many did, or that any account was penalized as a result. DFRLab's study counted hashtag use; the report feeds themselves do not appear to have been published before.
The boost list
The posts to praise came from a second feed. Three copies survive, captured on November 2, 2023, November 14, 2023, and July 30, 2024. They hold 250 entries linking to posts by 126 accounts, including the Israeli army, "Israel's" embassy in Washington, StandWithUs (seven posts), StandWithUs' Michael Dickson, Hillel Neuer of UN Watch, Douglas Murray, and Brigitte Gabriel. A listing shows that Words of Iron chose a post for amplification. It does not show that the account holder knew or took part, and nothing found suggests that any of them did.
The figures below come from a search of X's full archive on October 21, 2026, for replies carrying the tool's hashtag. They are minimums, since deleted posts and suspended accounts drop out.
CAM's chief executive
Roytman's post appears in the November 14 feed. Under it, at least 63 #wordsofiron replies were posted by 43 accounts between November 8 and 21, 2023. Fifty-nine are word for word from the list of 13; the other four carry the tool's hashtags with a few words of their own or none. Nine of the 43 accounts were opened after October 7, 2023.
In 2024, I reported that CAM worked in partnership with the Diaspora Ministry, one of the partners Ctech named behind Words of Iron, through the company Voices of Israel.
Asked for comment, a CAM spokesperson said, "Neither the Combat Antisemitism Movement nor Sacha Roytman have a relationship or even familiarity with Words of Iron, Israel Tech Guard, or the IsraelTechGuards." CAM also said it "is not a joint venture with the Diaspora Ministry through Voices of Israel", and that my earlier reporting was false, "based on the journalist's misreading of the Voices of Israel website." It added that the Ministry's full name is the "Ministry of Diaspora Affairs and Combating Antisemitism" and that I appeared to have "confused the second part of the Ministry's name with the Combat Antisemitism Movement." This article does not treat the Ministry's name as a reference to CAM: the Ctech passage quoted above is about the Ministry.
My 2024 article on CAM did not rest on that sentence alone. It showed that two of CAM's four senior advisors in 2020, Sima Vaknin-Gil, a former director-general, and Revital Yakin Krakowsky, came from the Ministry of Strategic Affairs, which signed the 2018 joint-venture agreement with Concert, as Voices of Israel was then known. The Guardian later reported that CAM "has publicly disclosed that it is a partner of Concert and Israel's ministry of diaspora affairs." CAM told the paper it "was not established by, nor is it influenced by, the Israeli government." I have not found a document naming CAM as a party to the joint-venture agreement; what the record shows is a partnership.
That is what the venture was built to produce. Its agreement was between the Ministry and Concert, but Concert's 2019 accounts say Concert had to raise "no less than 50%" of the cost of its work "from philanthropic sources and/or pro-Israel organisations," against "up to 50%" in matching from the Ministry, which it passed on, less 15 per cent overhead, "to the partner organization" (translated from Hebrew). Vaknin-Gil was open about why the partners, not the Ministry, should be seen. "One of the things that most characterises our work is a No Logo policy," she told the Knesset, as the Seventh Eye reported in December 2017: on any activity "defined as sensitive" you would "not see the stamp of the Ministry of Strategic Affairs" (translated from Hebrew). Some of the organizations, she said, did not want the public to know about their ties with the Israeli government. At a meeting with Erdan and INSS, a regime-friendly think tank, on June 14, 2016, according to the minutes, Vaknin-Gil even questioned the use of the term partnership. What was needed was "a better term than 'partnerships'" because in government, the word was associated with contracts or with competition with the Foreign Ministry (translated from Hebrew).
In an email of May 9, 2016, Assaf Orion of the Institute for National Security Studies recorded a long conversation with Vaknin-Gil that day, in which she said she had made clear to Erdan, and he was convinced, "that the government will not give direction on content in projects it funds" (translated from Hebrew); the email is among Benny Gantz's emails, hacked by Handala and released by DDoSecrets, and has not been independently verified. The government did not need to give direction: by 2020, two of the Ministry's own former officials, Vaknin-Gil herself and Yakin Krakowsky, were among CAM's senior advisors. The Guardian reported that a 2018 Justice Ministry memo, in files hacked from the Ministry and released by DDoSecrets, recommended "creating a new American nonprofit which Kela Shlomo/Concert could funnel money through, thereby providing distance between US nonprofits and the Israeli government." The paper said Vaknin-Gil was named in key documents on avoiding the US foreign-agents law and that CAM was set up a year later.
Mario Nawfal and the changing captives count
Mario Nawfal, an Australian entrepreneur whose news-aggregation account has about 3.95 million followers, appears three times in the feeds. On November 1, 2023, he posted that two children "hid in a closet at home while Hamas killed their parents," citing "Israel's" Channel 12. The next day's feed lists it.
Under that post, at least 83 #wordsofiron replies came from 55 accounts between November 1 and 8. Eighty match the scripted texts, and their timing shows the script being updated. From November 1 to 4, the replies read: "Please pray for the 203 hostages!" From November 5, they read: "241 hostages", as in the November 14 code. The most active account under the post posted eight of them; DFRLab had already named it for posting more than 300 copy-paste #wordsofiron replies on October 13 alone.
Three years later, CAM's own Antisemitism Research Center turned to Nawfal. On October 13, 2026, it reported that 40.5 per cent of 10,015 accounts amplifying his most-shared posts showed "strong signals of being bots, fake profiles, or inauthentic accounts." Its model counts "duplicate text" and "generic replies" as signs. It found "no copy-paste text across accounts" and "no evidence of a centrally operated network," and made no claim that Nawfal or his team ran any of the accounts. That study covered 2026. But the copy-paste replies under Nawfal's 2023 post and under CAM's own chief executive's came from a tool that Ctech linked to the Diaspora Ministry. Was CAM denouncing the inauthentic behaviour of an operation to which they appear to be linked?
A Canadian MP
The July 2024 boost feed shows the tool still choosing targets months into the war. It lists a post by Melissa Lantsman, then deputy leader of Canada's Conservative Party, marked "support" for the "NA" (North America) region. She had shared a photograph of a man at the Al-Quds Day rally in Toronto: "Peaceful protester wearing a pretend suicide vest at the #AlQudsDay rally in Toronto." The man's lawyer told The Globe and Mail he was wearing a belt made to hold paintball smoke grenades, and in November 2025, the man sued Lantsman for libel. He now faces a terrorism charge that, CBC News reported, relates to statements at later demonstrations, not the April rally; his lawyer denies the allegations. Because of the pending proceedings, he is not named here. Only two #wordsofiron replies can now be found under Lantsman's post.
What it shows
Volunteer messaging apps such as Act.IL came before it, and so did covert paid operations: DFRLab noted reports that the Diaspora Ministry funded a fake-account network run by the Tel Aviv firm STOIC. Words of Iron sat between the two. Many of its users were real people, and at least one, "Israel's" deputy consul in Miami, posted text matching its scripts. But the posts they praised were picked for them, the posts they reported were picked for them, the words were written for them, and from December 2023, the clicking could be done for them too.
David Miller