Indigenous leaders say Trump can't rewrite history with lake rename
The National Congress of American Indians opposes Trump's decision to rename Lake Ontario, citing Indigenous heritage and the 1794 Treaty of Canandaigua.
-
In the photo of a phone screen, a Google map showing Lake Ontario renamed as "Lake America" is seen Sunday, August 30, 2026, in St. Louis (AP)
The National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) has called on US President Donald Trump to reverse his decision to rename Lake Ontario "Lake America", warning that the move threatens to erase Indigenous history and disregard the longstanding cultural ties of Native American communities to the region, Newsweek reported.
The resolution, introduced by the Seneca Nation of Indians at the organization's October assembly and approved this week, calls on the federal government to stop using "Lake America" and restore recognition of the lake's Indigenous-derived name. The NCAI represents tribal governments across the United States.
The resolution states: "The National Congress of American Indians opposes the removal, replacement, or erasure of Indigenous names of lakes, rivers, mountains, and other geographic features."
It further urges federal, state, and local governments to preserve Indigenous geographic names "in consultation with affected Tribal Nations."
Tribal leaders challenge Trump's renaming decision
The resolution argues that changing Indigenous geographic names without consulting affected communities risks erasing the history of peoples whose connections to the land predate the United States.
It specifically identifies Lake Ontario as a body of water used by the Seneca and other Haudenosaunee peoples "since time immemorial for travel, trade, diplomacy, subsistence, and cultural practices."
The resolution adds that the lake bears "a commonly used name derived from Indigenous linguistic roots."
Lake Ontario is known in Seneca as "sga'nyodai'yoh", meaning "beautiful lake", while the Wendat term "ontari'io" means "the lake is beautiful, the lake is big."
Wendat Nation Grand Chief Pierre Picard accused Trump of "attempting to eradicate our history," saying the decision struck at "the very heart of our Wendat identity."
Trump seeking to 'eradicate' Indigenous history
"I want to tell him that it is unacceptable for us, as a nation, to have a president who can eradicate our history, our culture and our identity," Picard said.
"I don’t think anyone is able to change Trump’s mind, but for us it’s important for me as grand chief to bring our voice to the United States and tell them we are very upset with the decision."
The resolution follows an October statement by Indigenous organizations in the United States and Canada opposing the replacement of traditional geographic names.
NCAI President Mark Macarro said, "Long before there was a United States or Canada, Tribal Nations and First Nations knew these lands and waters by names rooted in our own languages, histories, and relationships to place."
He added, "Those histories cannot be rewritten by an Executive Order."
Treaty of Canandaigua at center of dispute
The Seneca Nation's opposition has also revived a dispute over the 1794 Treaty of Canandaigua, negotiated and signed during President George Washington's administration.
The agreement established peace and friendship between the United States and the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, of which the Seneca Nation is a member.
Former Seneca Nation President J. Conrad Seneca argued in August that Trump's decision violated the treaty and demonstrated disrespect for Indigenous communities connected to the lake.
"The President cannot assert ownership over our culture or erase it through irresponsible political action," he said.
However, the agreement does not explicitly prohibit changing the lake's name, and no court has ruled that Trump's executive order violates it.
Trump ordered Lake Ontario renamed in August
Trump signed Executive Order 14422 on August 27, instructing the Interior Department to rename Lake Ontario and remove references to its former name from federal geographic records.
"The United States is the greatest protector of the Great Lakes," the order stated.
The White House cited US investment, commercial shipping, military history, and the Coast Guard's role in maintaining navigation as justification for the decision.
Trump argued that the lake was "a tremendous asset to the United States and part of our Nation's heritage."
Carney rebuffs Trump's decision
Back in August, Carney dismissed Trump's decision to rename Lake Ontario “Lake America", saying Canadians would continue to refer to the lake by its established name.
He stressed that the name dates back more than 400 years, predating both the Confederation of Canada and the US Declaration of Independence.
"We know that America is changing. Their trading relationships, their foreign policies, their national monuments, their hydronyms. Canadians also know that naming reality means calling it Lake Ontario – then, now and always."
The name Lake Ontario comes from the Wendat word Ontari’io, which, appropriately, means “the lake is beautiful, the lake is big”. The name is more than 400 years old, predating both the Confederation of Canada and the Declaration of Independence of the United States of America. We know that America is changing. Their trading relationships, their foreign policies, their national monuments, their hydronyms. Canadians also know that naming reality means calling it Lake Ontario – then, now and always.
— Mark Carney (@MarkJCarney) August 27, 2026