EU’s 'green tariff' takes effect, reshaping global trade rules
The EU has launched its carbon border tax, forcing exporters of high-emission goods to account for pollution costs as concerns grow over trade frictions and UK uncertainty.
-
A cement production plant of Heidelberg Materials is pictured in Ennigerloh, Germany, Monday, Feb. 26, 2024. (AP)
The EU’s most significant overhaul of environmental trade rules in decades comes into force today, requiring companies that export high-carbon goods such as steel and cement into the bloc to demonstrate compliance with low-carbon standards or face financial penalties.
However, analysts warn that uncertainty over how the new system will be enforced, combined with the UK government’s failure to reach an agreement with Brussels, could create confusion during the early rollout.
Stephane Sejourne, the European Commission’s executive vice-president for prosperity and industrial strategy, said businesses should support the carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM), which is designed to prevent EU producers from being undercut by foreign competitors operating under weaker climate rules.
“European industrial producers should be encouraged – and not deterred – in their decarbonisation efforts,” he stressed.
“This CBAM reform brings crucial and long-awaited measures to ensure a level playing field between EU and non-EU industrial producers. By strengthening CBAM, we support our industry’s decarbonisation and secure European players’ competitiveness on the world stage,” he further added.
Pushback from trading partners fails to halt rollout
Many governments had anticipated the EU would retreat from the so-called “green tariff,” following the dilution of other environmental policies in recent years. Instead, the bloc pressed ahead, despite objections from China, the United States, Australia, and other major trading partners.
One consequence could be a loss of Chinese steel’s price advantage over European producers. Some analysts warn, however, that this could lead to surplus high-carbon goods being diverted into markets such as the UK at discounted prices. Britain is expected to introduce its own CBAM system next year.
Under the new framework, exporters selling into the EU must purchase certificates reflecting the carbon emissions generated during production. The mechanism is intended to stop competitors from countries with looser environmental rules from undercutting EU firms and to prevent “carbon leakage,” in which production shifts to jurisdictions with lower regulatory costs.
In its initial phase, the CBAM applies to iron and steel, aluminum, cement, hydrogen, electricity, and fertilizers.
UK industry sees CBAM as shield against cheap imports
Carbon border measures in both the EU and the UK would help protect domestic producers, said Diana Casey, executive director of the UK’s Mineral Products Association, which represents cement manufacturers.
“The challenge for us is that the rest of the world is not keeping up in terms of decarbonisation. That’s making production of products like cement much cheaper outside Europe as a consequence,” she said.
Casey noted that cement imports into the UK had surged from roughly 10% of the market a decade ago to around one-third today. “We need the CBAM to level that carbon cost playing field,” she said.
“We really do view it as quite fundamental to securing the future of cement production here in the UK,” she added.
Concerns over prices, but limited early impact expected
While EU manufacturers broadly support the CBAM, which mirrors the carbon costs they already face, some have warned that prices could rise as free emissions allowances under the EU’s emissions trading system are phased out, forcing firms to buy permits instead.
Adrien Assous, executive director of the Sandbag think tank, said any price impact was likely to be limited in the near term. “[The CBAM will have] a superbly beneficial impact for EU decarbonisation,” he said.
“But the impact of the CBAM [on prices and the economy] in the first few years is going to be quite mild. We’re arguing about a problem that is not very big because the amount of emissions covered is not very big,” he added.
British exporters had hoped to avoid CBAM penalties, given that the UK already regulates carbon emissions. Although London and Brussels have been negotiating a link between their carbon trading systems, no agreement has yet been reached.
As a result, UK companies could initially fall within the scope of the EU’s CBAM, after efforts to secure an early exemption failed.
EU signals minimal impact once carbon markets are linked
Wopke Hoekstra, the EU’s climate commissioner, said before Christmas that UK firms had little to fear from the CBAM, even without an immediate agreement. “The price it [the UK] will be paying is actually minimum,” he said.
“My assessment is that if the full linkage of the [carbon markets] has taken place, then it is likely that there is nothing in the bookkeeping and nothing in terms of the paperwork that still needs to be done,” he added.
Electricity exports from the UK, often renewable energy sent to the EU during periods of strong wind, should not fall under the CBAM, according to Adam Berman, director of policy and advocacy at Energy UK.
“[It would be] a baffling outcome to effectively disincentivise the imports of clean electricity into the EU,” he said.
Expansion planned from 2028
The EU has already signaled plans to widen the CBAM’s scope from 2028 to include goods that incorporate steel and aluminum, such as machinery and electrical appliances. The move is intended to prevent manufacturers from bypassing the rules by relocating production outside Europe.
A UK government spokesperson said efforts to secure an agreement with the EU were continuing.
“We are delivering on our commitment to secure a carbon linking agreement with the EU as soon as possible, which will exempt British businesses from over £7bn worth of export charges. We continue to work closely with the European Commission to support our world-class manufacturers and ensure that green investment in the UK results in decarbonisation here and overseas,” the spokesperson added.