A drug war in reverse: Trump pardons kingpins, strikes fishermen boats
Former DOJ officials, lawmakers, and policy experts say Trump’s sweeping clemency decisions have fueled an influence industry and disrupted traditional vetting systems.
-
Farmers protest against President Donald Trump's pardon of Honduras' former President Juan Orlando Hernandez in Tegucigalpa, Honduras, Thursday, Dec. 4, 2025 (AP)
US President Donald Trump began the year by issuing a striking series of clemency decisions that cut against his stated commitment to combating the nation’s drug crisis.
On his first full day in office, he pardoned Ross Ulbricht, the founder of Silk Road, who was convicted of running one of the largest online marketplaces for illegal drugs and contraband. In the months that followed, Trump extended clemency to several others, including Chicago gang figure Larry Hoover and Baltimore drug trafficker Garnett Gilbert Smith.
Most recently, he pardoned former Honduran president Juan Orlando Hernandez, who had been serving a 45-year sentence for turning his administration into a “narco-state” that enabled the shipment of more than 400 tons of cocaine into the United States.
The pardons stand in stark contrast to Trump’s campaign claim to aggressively combat drug trafficking and halt the flow of narcotics across the southern border. According to a Washington Post analysis, Trump has pardoned or commuted the sentences of at least 10 individuals convicted of drug offenses since his second term began. During his first four years in office, he granted clemency to nearly 90 drug offenders.
Foreign policy tensions and sharp criticism
At the same time, Trump has threatened military action against Venezuela for allegedly enabling drug trafficking and has pressed the Pentagon to authorize lethal force against suspected smuggling vessels in the Caribbean. Critics say the contrasting approaches send mixed signals.
Sen. Tim Kaine questioned the strategy on the Senate floor. “President Trump is claiming to be taking action to stop the flow of narcotics into the United States… How does this protect Americans from the flow of narcotics entering our country?”
The White House has pushed back on claims of inconsistency. Press secretary Karoline Leavitt insisted that pardoning Hernández does not undercut the administration’s rationale for targeting suspected traffickers.
“I think that President Trump has been quite clear… to stop these illegal narcotics from coming to our borders,” she said, arguing that the president is correcting past injustices by reversing decisions from what she called a “weaponized Justice Department” under the previous administration.
Attacks on Biden and 'autopen' claims
White House spokeswoman Abigail Jackson defended Trump’s clemency record and pivoted to criticism of former President Joe Biden. “The only pardons anyone should be critical of are from President Autopen… that’s not to mention the proactive pardons he ‘signed’ for his family members like Hunter on his way out the door.”
Trump and his allies have repeatedly, and without evidence, claimed that Biden’s staff used an autopen to sign official clemency documents.
Trump has relied on his pardon power more aggressively this term, granting pardons to nearly all of the roughly 1,500 individuals charged in the January 6, 2021, Capitol attack. He has also pardoned about a dozen lawmakers, mostly Republicans, including Rep. Henry Cuellar, who faced charges of bribery, money laundering, and conspiracy. In contrast, he granted clemency to just over 230 people during his first term, only two of them in his first year.
A growing influence industry
The surge in pardons has spurred a lucrative lobbying ecosystem. Public filings show more than $2.1 million spent this year on firms specializing in securing pardons and commutations, double the amount reported in 2024. Some individuals seeking clemency reportedly paid up to $1 million to people with connections to Trump.
Experts say the administration’s strikes on boats near Venezuela have had little impact, noting that those maritime routes are not typically used to transport drugs to the United States. Most fentanyl, the leading cause of overdose deaths, is produced in Mexico and smuggled by land. The administration has not provided clear evidence that the vessels targeted were carrying narcotics or heading toward the US.
War Secretary Pete Hegseth defended the approach, saying they paused operations because “it’s hard to find boats to strike right now, which is the entire point… deterrence has to matter.”
But experts dispute that deterrence has been achieved. As Regina LaBelle noted, “Drug trafficking is like water. It’s going to find a way to get in.”
Public health concerns amid funding cuts
Critics of US drug policy argue that enforcement-heavy strategies fail to address addiction, the primary driver of overdose deaths. While overdose rates declined near the end of Biden’s term after years of fentanyl-driven increases, advocates warn that cuts to Medicaid and treatment services could reverse those gains. The Drug Policy Alliance estimates that at least $345 million has been cut this year from federal programs supporting addiction treatment.
Theshia Naidoo said, “At a time we’re escalating these military campaigns and divesting from this health infrastructure, it highlights the contradiction in claiming that these military actions are saving American lives from overdose.”
US officials have long accused Venezuela’s president, Nicolas Maduro, of involvement in drug trafficking, with no proof provided. The Southern District of New York indicted him in 2020. Citing that case on Fox News, Secretary of State Marco Rubio argued, “Until the president decided to do something about it, no one disputed that Maduro was in the drug trafficking business.” Hernandez faced charges brought by the same office.
Inconsistency on drug policy
Jeffrey Singer of the Cato Institute described Trump’s drug policy as erratic, noting his support for legalizing recreational marijuana in Florida even as he tightened restrictions on hemp. “There’s no consistency,” Singer said. “He pardons a drug trafficker, but orders the shooting on-site of drug traffickers who are not in this country.”
Some Republicans have also criticized the move. Sen. Thom Tillis called it “a horrible message,” arguing it made little sense to consider military action against Venezuela for alleged trafficking while pardoning a leader implicated in similar conduct.
Trump has defended his recent pardons as correcting wrongful prosecutions. On Truth Social, he wrote that respected figures told him Hernandez was “treated very harshly and unfairly.”
Breakdown of the traditional clemency system
Liz Oyer, former head of the Justice Department’s pardon office before Trump dismissed her, said past presidents typically reserved clemency for nonviolent drug offenders who demonstrated rehabilitation. Hernandez, she argued, “does not meet that threshold.”
“The pardoning of drug kingpins is virtually unheard of,” she added, noting that Trump’s approach reflects the erosion of the traditional, merit-based vetting system in favor of one driven by influence and access.
Longtime Trump associate Roger Stone said he personally forwarded Hernandez’s letter to the president, concluding the charges were “politically motivated and false.” He denied receiving payment.
Angela McArdle, former Libertarian Party chair, said she believed Ulbricht’s pardon served both electoral strategy and political signaling. “I think he understood that Ross Ulbricht was a political prisoner… It was the same Southern District of New York that locked Ross up that went after President Trump.”
Read more: War on drugs or war for trusteeship? Petro tears down US narrative