Iran's Hormuz leverage reshaping global power balance: NYT
An NYT opinion piece argues that Iran’s growing leverage over the Strait of Hormuz is reshaping global power dynamics by disrupting energy flows and challenging US dominance.
-
An LPG (liquefied petroleum gas) tanker sails in waters north of the Bab el-Mandeb Strait in Mokha, Yemen, Monday, April 6, 2026 (AP Photo/Abdulnasser Alseddik)
In an opinion piece published in The New York Times on Tuesday, writer Robert A. Pape argues that the global balance of power is undergoing a structural shift, with Iran emerging as a new center of influence not through economic or military dominance, but through its leverage over critical energy routes.
Pape contends that long-standing assumptions about global power, centered on the United States, China, and Russia, are becoming outdated. Instead, he points to Iran’s position along the Strait of Hormuz as a decisive factor in reshaping geopolitical dynamics. The waterway, which carries roughly one-fifth of the world’s oil and liquefied natural gas, has come under tighter strategic control amid ongoing US-Israeli aggression on Iran, with Iranian retaliatory measures reshaping the terms of access and navigation.
Strait control dynamics
According to the analysis, Iran has effectively established a form of selective control over the strait without fully shutting it down. While tankers continue to pass through, traffic has sharply declined due to heightened risks. “You can control the strait without closing it,” Pape notes, explaining that intermittent attacks and credible threats have been sufficient to drive up insurance costs and deter shipping.
The disruption has exposed what the author describes as a fundamental asymmetry: securing uninterrupted maritime flows requires constant military coverage, whereas limited, sporadic strikes are enough to undermine confidence in the route. This dynamic, he argues, places the United States and its allies at a disadvantage.
Pape further suggests that the implications extend beyond immediate military concerns. Energy markets rely not only on supply, but on reliability. As uncertainty increases, insurance premiums rise, freight costs escalate, and governments begin treating energy access as a strategic vulnerability rather than a routine market function.
Shifting energy order
The piece also points to shifting regional calculations. Gulf states, heavily dependent on stable exports, may be compelled to adjust their policies in response to persistent instability, potentially accommodating Iran’s growing influence. At the same time, major Asian economies, including China, India, Japan, and South Korea, face heightened exposure due to their reliance on Gulf energy.
Pape warns that prolonged disruption could trigger broader economic consequences, including inflationary pressures, currency strain, and deteriorating trade balances. He draws parallels to past oil shocks, suggesting that sustained instability could revive conditions resembling the stagflation of the 1970s.
The analysis also highlights converging interests among Iran, Russia, and China. While not necessarily forming a formal alliance, each stands to benefit from current conditions, whether through elevated energy prices, strategic positioning, or expanded access to supply.
Energy crossroads
In a more speculative scenario, Pape raises the possibility of a de facto energy bloc capable of restricting supply to Western markets, a development he says would carry severe consequences for the United States and Europe.
Ultimately, the author frames the situation as a strategic crossroads for Washington: either commit to a prolonged effort to secure the Strait of Hormuz or adapt to a new global energy order in which American dominance is no longer guaranteed. He concludes that the outcome of the current war could have lasting effects, arguing that “this is a transformational war” with the potential to reshape the international system if current trends persist.
Read more: Beyond rescue: The hidden objectives behind the US mission in Isfahan