Netanyahu inflated Iran nuclear threat to justify 2 wars, study finds
Mada al-Carmel research says Netanyahu's policies hyped up a "threat" by Iran; Netanyahu had spent three decades claiming that a bomb was near.
-
Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu shows an illustration of a cartoon bomb during his address to the 67th session of the United Nations General Assembly at U.N. headquarters, Sept. 27, 2012. (AP Photo/Richard Drew)
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu exaggerated the “Iranian nuclear threat” for political purposes and used it to justify two wars on Iran, according to a study by the Mada al-Carmel research center. The study says his policies “made the threat more complex rather than containing it.”
The study finds that Netanyahu spent more than 30 years presenting Iran’s nuclear program as an “existential danger” to “Israel,” while casting himself as “the leader capable of saving the Jewish people from another historic catastrophe.”
It argues that his policies helped “create the conditions for this threat to grow” before he cited it to “justify” the wars of June 2025 and February 2026.
The researchers point to a 1993 article in which Netanyahu predicted Iran would hold a nuclear weapon by 1999 and called for international action to prevent it. The prediction did not materialize, but he kept describing the program as an “imminent threat.”
A deadline that kept moving
Public records show the same pattern. Netanyahu said in 1992 that Iran was three to five years from a bomb, and his 1995 book "Fighting Terrorism" gave a window of five to seven years at most.
He told the US Congress in 1996 that the deadline was “extremely close,” and in 2009 he told a visiting congressional delegation that Iran was one to two years away, according to a US diplomatic cable. At the UN General Assembly in 2012, he held up a cartoon bomb and said Iran was less than a year from one.
Documents leaked in 2015 showed that Mossad told South African intelligence weeks after that speech that Iran was not performing the activity needed to produce weapons.
Two wars that exposed the limits of force
The first US-Israeli war on Iran was launched on June 13, 2025, and lasted 12 days. The study notes that regime change was not initially among its declared objectives, and that Netanyahu added the goal later.
The second war, launched by “Israel” with US participation in February 2026, continued his reliance on military force to bring about “strategic change in Iran.”
According to the study, both wars exposed the limits of “Israel’s” ability to destroy or damage Iran’s nuclear program.
It concludes that the survival of Iran’s government and the preservation of its nuclear capabilities undermined Netanyahu’s narrative and cast doubt on his claims to have “destroyed Iran’s nuclear program.”
The same claims days before the election
Netanyahu renewed the allegations this week. Speaking at an IOF officer graduation ceremony on Wednesday, he said Iran was once again trying to develop nuclear weapons and that Iranian Leader Sayyed Mojtaba Khamenei had “pulled the pin,” according to Ynet.
He added that he had ordered the IOF and Mossad to pursue the overthrow of the Iranian government.
In an interview with Israel Hayom published Wednesday, he said Sayyed Khamenei had ordered the nuclear effort accelerated and that Iran was seeking to complete the weaponization system needed for a bomb.
In a separate interview with The Jerusalem Post published the same day, he said Iran would have “atomic bombs” to destroy “Israel” had the two wars not been launched. He also told Fox News Sunday that Iran was building intercontinental missiles and pursuing nuclear weapons to threaten American cities.