Pentagon 'not leaving NATO,' just floating punishment ideas for allies
Reports suggest internal US debates over NATO focus on disciplining allied behavior rather than exiting the alliance.
-
War Secretary Pete Hegseth speaks to members of the media during a press briefing at the Pentagon in Washington, April 16, 2026. (AP)
Internal Pentagon documents do not propose a US withdrawal from NATO or the closure of American military bases in Europe as part of any response to allies’ refusal to support operations against Iran, Reuters reported Friday, citing an unnamed US official.
Earlier this week, Politico reported, citing three European diplomats and a Pentagon official, that the White House had created a “naughty and nice” list ranking NATO members based on their contributions to the alliance. However, details of possible rewards or penalties were not disclosed.
The US official also declined to confirm whether any potential measures under consideration include reducing the number of American troops stationed in Europe.
Possible “punitive” measures outlined
According to the report, internal Pentagon emails reportedly outline several options viewed as punitive toward NATO allies. These include suspending Spain’s membership in the alliance and revisiting the US position on the United Kingdom’s sovereignty claims over the Falkland Islands.
The official reportedly said suspending Spain would have a limited operational impact but significant symbolic weight, though no details were provided on how such a step could be implemented.
Another option mentioned in the email reportedly involves removing representatives of countries labeled as “difficult” from prominent NATO positions.
Intensified criticism of NATO allies
Trump has repeatedly criticized NATO members over their response to the war on Iran, particularly their reluctance to support naval efforts aimed at securing the Strait of Hormuz, which was closed to international shipping following the start of the war on February 28.
In an interview for Reuters on April 1, Trump questioned the strength of US commitment to NATO, responding to questions about potential withdrawal by saying, “Wouldn’t you if you were me?”
He has also targeted UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer, accusing him of being “cowardly” for not joining US military action against Iran, stating Britain was “No Winston Churchill,” and dismissing British aircraft carriers as “toys".
Britain initially declined a US request to support offensive operations from its bases, later agreeing only to defensive missions intended to protect civilians in the region, including British nationals, during Iranian retaliation.
War Secretary Pete Hegseth has acknowledged that the Iran war exposed divisions within NATO, noting that while Iran’s longer-range missile systems cannot reach the United States, they are capable of striking European territory.
“We get questions, or roadblocks, or hesitations ... You don't have much of an alliance if you have countries that are not willing to stand with you when you need them,” Hegseth said earlier this month at the Pentagon.
A Pentagon spokesperson told Reuters the department is preparing “credible options” for the president in response to allied actions, emphasizing that NATO cannot function as a “one-way street,” while declining to comment on internal discussions.
Read more: Pentagon internal email outlines US options to punish NATO allies