Sayyed Nasrallah's influence extended beyond Lebanon | Excl.
Mohammad Marandi and Mathew Hoh discuss Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah’s legacy, the culture of resistance, Hezbollah’s regional influence and shifting US perceptions.
-
Iranian professor of English literature and Orientalism at the University of Tehran Mohammad Marandi and senior fellow at the Eisenhower Media Network Matthew Hoh (Al Mayadeen)
Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah built a culture of resistance that outlasted his own killing and reshaped how Americans understand the resistance, Professor Mohammad Marandi and Matthew Hoh, an assistant director at the Eisenhower Media Network, said on Monday.
Speaking on Al Mayadeen's Iran and the World: The Great Standoff, Marandi said that he met Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah for several hours as part of a delegation, and the encounter left a lasting impression. "They were always extraordinarily impressed, not just by the depth of his knowledge, but by his extraordinary humility," he said of those who knew him.
Marandi noted that Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah took charge of Hezbollah after the killing of his predecessor, Sayyed Abbas Musawi, and that "one of the first to be martyred under his command was his own son, Sayyed Hadi", a contrast, he said, with the children of other Lebanese party leaders who live abroad.
He said Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah combined political skill with moral seriousness. "He was extraordinary at politics," Marandi said, even as he remained "an extremely moral person" and, as he put it, "extremely humble."
He rejected any suggestion of inflated praise. "He was not an ordinary man," Marandi continued. "And often people like to exaggerate about leaders. But with regard to Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah, there's no exaggeration."
Building a culture of resistance beyond a single leader
Marandi argued that Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah's most important impact was the culture he built among the people.
He said the resistance withstood a campaign that had Western support and backing from Lebanese political figures he termed traitors, and that after his death the people remained steadfast and the adversary failed.
"He created a culture among the people, a culture of resistance, a culture of dignity and honor that made them prepared to fight come what may, regardless of whether he was alive or not," Marandi stated. The same pattern, he said, appeared after Sayyed Hashem Safieddine was killed. "That did not bend the will of the people of Lebanon," he said.
Marandi also pointed to Iran, saying that when Sayyed Ali Khamenei was martyred, Iranians remained resilient and nothing changed. He said he was in Lebanon when Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah was assasinated and in Tehran when Sayyed Khamenei was assassinated, and that the scenes and mood were the same: "Defiance, courage, and a depth of political and spiritual understanding among both the people of Lebanon and Iran."
That depth, he argued, ultimately defeated both Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu.
Military capability and regional influence
Marandi said Hezbollah faced disadvantages that set it apart from other resistance fronts. Unlike Gaza, which he said operated under a unified command with Islamic Jihad in full coordination with Hamas, Lebanon contained a population he characterized as traitors.
"They have always been stabbing the resistance in the back," he said. Given those conditions, he argued, "for Hezbollah to create a military capability, and to be able to do politics so effectively, needed a leader of extraordinary capabilities."
He said Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah expanded the influence of the resistance to Iraq, Yemen and Palestine, and to parts of Latin America, Asia and Africa.
"His influence went far beyond Lebanon," Marandi said, adding that Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah's effect on Iranian politics, decision-making and the culture of resistance was enormous.
Rejection of the proxy characterization
Marandi disputed the common description of Hezbollah as an Iranian proxy, saying the influence runs in both directions. "If anything, the amount of influence that the resistance in Lebanon has had in Iran is no less than the influence that Iran has had on Lebanon," noting that Iranian cities carry the Hezbollah flag because "it means resistance. It means supporting the oppressed."
Hezbollah raised its voice for Gaza and for Yemen even when doing so carried a heavy price, Marandi pointed out, whether "from Israel or from the oil- and gas-rich regional states bound to the West."
"It means standing up against aggression," he said of what the flag represents, going further and adding "It means supporting the children of Gaza. It means supporting the people of Yemen."
Arab states and the absence of pressure on 'Israel'
Hoh said the past three years showed inaction by Arab states on behalf of the Palestinians, with nothing beyond lip service. "Nothing but lip service from those states," he said, adding that attempts in 2023 for Palestinians to negotiate with the Israeli government drew "no real support" and no weight from those states.
He asked what other avenue was available to the Palestinians besides armed resistance, since "negotiations, diplomacy, political action were not going to occur because no one was willing to support them."
Hoh said Arab states fought alongside the Israelis in the war against Iran, "not just shooting down missiles and drones, but actively firing weapons of their own into Iran." He said the record shows how Netanyahu would spend entire days with Emirati, Saudi, Kuwaiti and Qatari leadership while none of them applied pressure or used leverage on behalf of the Palestinians.
He said he believed the war would have occurred regardless, but that the decades of Arab inaction help explain how the region reached this point.
Marandi made a similar argument, saying the region's regimes are overwhelmingly in the American camp, some as family dictatorships and some within NATO, and that all of them offer only lip service to the Palestinian cause. "That's all empty lip service, and they make no sacrifices," he said. He said the absence of sanctions on them is because none poses a risk to American power or to "Israel".
American perceptions and the shift in public understanding
Hoh said most Americans historically could not identify Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah and "understood him, if at all, through a caricature," noting that US media routinely appended the phrase Iranian proxy to references to Hezbollah, Lebanon or Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah.
"That's true for most American mainstream or corporate media," he said.
Hoh called the assassination of Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah a murder carried out "in the most dastardly way," noting that it took place "under the perfidy or the pretext of coming negotiations."
Hoh compared the treatment of Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah to that of Yahya Sinwar of Hamas, saying a derogatory nickname was invented for him and used by the American press. He said most Americans held a cartoonish view of Sinwar until they watched the events in Gaza unfold on their screens.
Over the past two years, Hoh argued, American public opinion has shifted, with polls showing that Americans do not want the United States to support "Israel", to be involved in these wars, or to maintain its empire in the Middle East.
He said many now see the United States and "Israel" as wearing the black hats and figures like Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah as wearing the white hats, a reference to old American Western films. "They were the ones wearing the white hats," Hoh said.
"They were the ones who were the good guys." He said these men are increasingly viewed not as terrorists but as freedom fighters carrying out resistance rather than acts of terror.
How US citizens' understanding of resistance changed
Marandi said the American political class, which he said is tied to the imperial narrative, has not changed its view, but that the general American public now has a better understanding of what resistance and martyrdom mean. He said this understanding extends across Lebanon, Palestine, Iran, Syria, Iraq and Yemen, and undercuts the idea of Western superiority or supremacy.
Hoh said Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah and those around him understood that their future and vulnerabilities were tied to others, and that the regimes oppressing them were the same ones oppressing the Palestinians.
He said Hezbollah under Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah immediately moved to support the Palestinian resistance while much of the world offered "empty and worthless platitudes, words of support."
Marandi said the flag of Hezbollah carries meaning for Iranians because it represents support for the oppressed. He said the regimes of the region were doing to Yemen what "Israel" was doing to Gaza, and that Hezbollah raised its voice wherever it saw such actions, at great cost.