Trump faces pressure in Hormuz, Congress: Marandi, Watkins | Excl.
Marandi warns that renewed US strikes could draw Gulf states deeper into the war, while Watkins questions the intelligence Washington has presented about Iran.
-
University of Tehran Professor Mohammad Marandi and Media commentator and author Laurie Watkins on Al Mayadeen's The Grand Standoff: Iran and the World (Designed by Fatima Attieh for Al Mayadeen English)
Iran is increasing pressure on US President Donald Trump in the Strait of Hormuz to make Washington honor the memorandum of understanding he signed, University of Tehran Professor Mohammad Marandi stated.
Speaking on Al Mayadeen's The Grand Standoff: Iran and the World on Thursday, Marandi argued that even if Trump walked away from the US-Israeli war on Iran, tanker traffic would remain disrupted until Washington fulfilled its commitments.
On her part, US media commentator and author Laurie Watkins said Trump also faced a decision at home. When Democrats take control of the House and Senate in January, she said, he will have to reckon with lawmakers who can decide whether the Pentagon receives more money and who are likely to demand testimony about the conduct of the war.
During his visit to China, Trump told Fox News, "We'll see what happens after January 1," without explaining what would change on that date. Watkins said his remarks left US allies and Arab Gulf partners guessing whether Washington would continue negotiations, resume strikes alongside "Israel", or act alone.
Marandi warns of tanker shortages and a wider war
Marandi said Iran stepped up strikes on vessels defying its transit orders, warning that the cumulative loss of tankers could make it harder to move oil even beyond the Strait, because the number of vessels available to carry it is finite.
Trump could implement the memorandum without publicly acknowledging that he was doing so, Marandi maintained. But if he withdrew without carrying out its terms, "that still won't normalize the situation in the Strait of Hormuz." Watkins said Washington needed to spell out what it was prepared to offer in talks over shipping, including whether it would withdraw US ships and military personnel from the region.
Marandi also argued that Iran was better prepared for renewed hostilities than it was at the outset of the war. He said Tehran lifted its previous missile range limit of roughly 2,000 kilometers, noting that the further US forces had to operate from Iran, the more difficult and costly another campaign would become.
If Washington attacked Iranian infrastructure, Marandi warned, the consequences would extend to Gulf states hosting US forces and could trigger a global economic crisis. Watkins said Tehran's warning to regional governments was explicit: allowing Washington to use their territory for strikes could expose them to retaliation. She added that shifting US naval forces from the Pacific to West Asia raised questions about military readiness elsewhere.
Both guests question case for renewed strikes
The Iranian professor drew a parallel between allegations about Iranian chemical weapons and a possible "dirty bomb" and the claims Washington used to build public support for the 2003 invasion of Iraq. He argued that the succession of accusations was preparing Americans for another attack on Iran.
Watkins questioned whether Washington independently corroborated the intelligence behind those allegations. "And are officials distinguishing what Iran could do from what it is preparing to do?" she asked. She said that distinction mattered when officials were presenting a possible threat as grounds for military action.
On Iran's nuclear program, Watkins called for International Atomic Energy Agency inspectors to regain access to bombed facilities so they could establish what remained after the strikes. She also pointed to a joint statement by Iran, Russia, and China linking the full resumption of inspections to an end to hostilities and threats of further attacks. Tehran, she argued, was showing Washington that it had diplomatic backing for its position.
Both guests saw little progress on Iran from Trump's talks in China. Marandi said that appearing alongside Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin in fact benefited Moscow by giving Putin equal standing at the meeting. Watkins criticized Trump for using the visit for photo opportunities while differences over Iran and the war in Ukraine went unresolved.
Watkins questions whether Congress will fund Trump's Pentagon agenda
Watkins described Trump as a "lame-duck president" heading into January. She pointed to House Speaker Mike Johnson's decision to send lawmakers home a day before they were due to finish voting as a sign that even the current House leadership had little appetite for taking up contentious issues.
The incoming Congress, she said, could call administration officials to testify about the war. It would also have to decide whether to authorize more money for a War Department led by Pete Hegseth.
"There are going to be continued calls for him to resign because of his inability to effectively run this department and our military," Watkins said. "He is not qualified to do so, has never been qualified."
Watkins argued that Hegseth's advice to Trump had endangered US personnel, allies, and Arab Gulf partners. European allies, she added, remained unwilling to join Washington in the war.
Marandi urges Iraqi government, Resistance to avert confrontation
In Iraq, the immediate concern was a standoff over Jurf al-Nasr, southwest of Baghdad. The Iraqi government approved a plan for army, police, and Popular Mobilization Forces units to take over security in the area. Kataib Hezbollah Secretary-General Abu Hussein al-Hamidawi met with Esmail Qaani, commander of Iran's Quds Force, and Iraqi leaders to discuss the redeployment.
Marandi urged Iraq's government, Armed Forces, and Resistance groups to work together, noting that "under no circumstances should there be internal strife in Iraq."
"Iraq's security and stability is key to the security and stability of the region," he said. He accused Trump of withholding Iraqi funds to extract political concessions from Baghdad, saying ordinary Iraqis bore the cost when their government struggled to pay salaries because of US policies.
Watkins said the arrangement could avert an immediate armed confrontation. The longer-term question, she argued, was whether Baghdad would regain effective authority over the territory while armed groups retained their weapons and influence. She urged Washington to let Iraq settle that question without threatening consequences if Baghdad rejected US advice.
Read more: US pressure will not force Iran to concede: Marandi, McGovern | Excl.