War on Iran tearing apart Trump's political coalition, analysis finds
Trump’s decision to wage war on Iran has fractured his 2024 electoral coalition, with high-profile defections and polling showing fewer than a quarter of Americans believe the war has been worth the cost.
-
MAGA hats are seen on the desk as President Donald Trump speaks with reporters after signing executive orders in the Oval Office of the White House, Wednesday, April 23, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)
Less than a quarter of Americans polled in mid-April said that the US-Israeli war on Iran has been worth it, a number likely to decrease further as the war's economic costs continue to mount globally. However, Trump faces no imminent revolt from Congress despite overseeing one of the most unpopular wars in US history.
High-profile defectors such as Tucker Carlson and Marjorie Taylor Greene have accused the president of abandoning his supporters. Hawkish Republicans respond by waving polls that show strong support for the war among those who identify as "MAGA Republicans."
However, the debate about MAGA versus non-MAGA Republicans obscures the fact that Trump's choice to go to war has wrecked the broader coalition that elected him.
Two-thirds of Americans oppose the war
Sixty-six percent of Americans disapprove of the decision to go to war, while 68 percent are opposed to the use of ground troops in Iran. Sixty-nine percent are concerned about the war's economic impact, particularly on fuel prices, and 64 percent tell pollsters that they are not confident in the president's ability to resolve the crisis.
While 77 percent of Republican-leaning Americans support the war, including 90 percent of self-identified "MAGA Republicans," Trump's 2024 winning coalition included many who are not hardcore MAGA loyalists.
Hardcore MAGA Republicans made up only about 30 percent of Trump voters during the 2024 election, according to a study by the group More in Common.
Younger Republicans and non-college-educated voters turn against war
Among other segments of Trump voters, support for the war is much lower. Republicans under 30 are 30 points less likely to support the war than their older partisan counterparts. White, non-college-educated voters, a core Trump demographic, have swung sharply against the president, with approval dropping from over 30 percent in 2025 to underwater today.
Podcasters Joe Rogan and Theo Von have both described the war as a betrayal of those who voted for Trump. More in Common's polling shows that only about one-quarter of what it describes as the "reluctant right" segment of Trump's electoral base supports the war.
Joe Kent, who resigned as director of the National Counterterrorism Center in protest of the war, explicitly called out Israeli influence in his resignation letter as opposed to the principle of America First.
Chris Caldwell, a longtime defender of Trump in the public space, now argues that "the attack on Iran is so wildly inconsistent with the wishes of his own base, so diametrically opposed to their reading of the national interest, that it is likely to mark the end of Trumpism as a project."
War offers lessons for future candidates
While Trump's core MAGA base does not appear ready to desert him over the Iran war, much of the broader coalition that elected him has already done so.
Vice President JD Vance, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, and other Republican candidates associated with this administration may struggle to distance themselves from this unpopular war in the future.
Trump's electoral success in 2024 was undoubtedly linked to dissatisfaction with the previous administration's foreign policy, particularly regarding Gaza. Having now lost much of that coalition, the analysis questions whether any other politician can capture it.
Read More: Trump's attack on former allies exposes splintered MAGA coalition