Why Renee Good’s killing reminds me of Martin Niemoeller’s 'First They Came' poem
The killing of Renee Good by an ICE agent exposes how state violence, long ignored when targeting racialised communities, inevitably turns on the privileged, echoing Martin Niemoeller’s warning about silence in the face of injustice.
-
Niemoeller’s confession describes an escalatory trajectory of repression which the second Trump administration has followed to a fault. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab el-Hajj)
In 1976, German Lutheran pastor Martin Niemoeller, whose (albeit late) opposition to the Nazi regime landed him in Hitler’s concentration camps, gave a sermon in the city of Kaiserslautern after which there was a discussion with the congregation.
Among other things, he was asked why ordinary people did not wake up to what was happening around them after the anti-Jewish Kristallnacht pogroms of 1938.
Niemoeller’s confession would later gain prominence in the Anglosphere as the “First They Came” poem:
When the Nazis came for the communists, I kept quiet; I wasn't a communist.
When they came for the trade unionists, I kept quiet; I wasn't a trade unionist.
When they locked up the social democrats, I kept quiet; I wasn't a social democrat.
When they came for me, there was no one left to protest.
The execution-style homicide of Renee Good, a 37-year-old white woman and US citizen in Minneapolis by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent Jonathan Ross, has reminded me of Niemoeller’s cautionary tale.
Many versions of his words exist, but they all carry the same message: that injustice against one is injustice against all, and that silence is not merely complicity, but has a boomerang effect which will “return to sender” that unopposed injustice, ultimately not sparing even the most privileged among us.
Answering the call of civic duty to her fellow community members of color who have been the target of harrowing state violence since Trump returned to power, Good, an active volunteer in neighbourhood patrols that monitor ICE raids, understood the concept of shared humanity.
Sadly, many others in a position of (white) privilege, have not.
Missed warning signs
Niemoeller’s confession describes an escalatory trajectory of repression which the second Trump administration’s weaponisation of immigration law and militarised anti-immigration push has followed to a fault.
After going ballistic on legal temporary residents, green card holders and US citizens of color, Trump and his ilk are now not even sparing white, middle class Americans.
To arrive at this moment in which someone from the US’s white dominant culture can be killed in an anti-immigration raid conducted by what is effectively a state-sponsored militia, liberal white America, now up in arms, had to wilfully ignore every warning sign of governmental despotism along the way.
In June/July 2025, Los Angeles erupted in protest against ICE’s reign of terror in the largest and most ethnically diverse city in the US.
The fact that this was the first time since 1965 that National Guard troops were deployed to a state without a governor’s consent should illustrate the scale and severity of one of many early warning signs of things to come just five months into Trump’s second term in office.
Two months before Minneapolis mayor Jacob Frey told ICE’s masked goons to “get the f*** out of” his city in the wake of Good’s killing, Evanston mayor Daniel Biss had warned that his community was “under invasion from our own federal government.”
Why wasn’t he taken seriously? Rewatching the footage of those aggressive raids in Evanston, it becomes clear that it was only a matter of time that ICE’s power-drunk, out-of-control recklessness would kill someone during one of its kidnapping sprees.
2025 saw the highest number of deaths in ICE custody in over two decades, according to data compiled by The Guardian from various sources, including the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and ICE itself.
Each one of these deaths in custody was a missed opportunity to collectively rise up against the Trump regime’s all-consuming authoritarianism, boisterous white supremacy and policies of organised cruelty.
Human interest storification of white lives
Sadly, the nationwide protests and upscaled news coverage in the wake of Good’s killing did not begin after the first person was killed in an ICE raid; they were a reaction to the first white person killed.
It was only after the plethora of heartfelt media tributes to Good’s life that many learned about Keith Porter Jr., a 43-year-old Black man and father of two who was killed on December 31 by an off-duty ICE agent in Los Angeles.
Or Josué Castro Rivera, a 24-year old Honduran gardener who was fatally struck by a passing vehicle in Virginia while being hounded by ICE in October 2025.
Or Silverio Villegas Gonzaléz, a Mexican father who, similar to Good, had just dropped off his children at school and daycare before an ICE agent shot him dead during a traffic stop in a Chicago suburb the month before.
The mainstream media’s human interest storification of white lives cut short and its footnoote-like treatment of Black and Brown people killed by white supremacist state violence says much about whose lives matter in America and whose don’t.
May Renee Good’s heinous killing serve as a reminder to internalise Niemoeller’s words on the collective nature of resistance and the dangers of inaction in the face of fascist tyranny.
Timo Al-Farooq