Germany’s political left has failed the litmus test of Palestine
Germany’s political left is in shambles, and that is bad news for Palestinian solidarity in a country where crackdowns on anti-genocide protests have been among the most vicious, the most violent, and the most lawless.
-
Palestine is the moral litmus test, and Germany’s left is failing it (Illustrated by Zeinab al-Hajj; Al Mayadeen English)
On November 22, the federal arbitration commission of Germany’s left-wing party DIE LINKE confirmed the expulsion of Ramsis Kilani, a Palestinian-German activist, for opposing "Israel’s" genocide in Gaza on the grounds of “behaviour that is damaging to the party.”
The alleged “damaging behaviour” included, among other things, his sharing of a social media post by Jewish group Jüdische Stimme that criticised "Israel".
Pro-Staatsräson party cadres have been desperately trying to paint Kilani as a terrorism sympathiser and an antisemite because of his support for both the Palestinian people’s right to armed resistance in accordance with international law and a one-state solution in Palestine.
The decision to expel him is a cruel one, made in full knowledge of the more than 70,000 Palestinians slaughtered in the last 26 months of "Israel’s" live-streamed and bragged-about colonial war of extermination, not to mention the commission’s stone-cold indifference to Kilani’s personal history of trauma.
In 2014, during one of Israel’s many bombing campaigns on Gaza, seven of his family members were killed, including his father, stepmother, and half-siblings.
Kilani’s expulsion marks yet another failure of the German left to include Palestinian liberation in its progressive politics, a failure borne out of a combination of overcompensating philosemitism in response to Germany’s Jewish holocaust guilt and textbook anti-Arab and anti-Muslim racism.
It is also bound to further entrench the glaring divide between anti-Zionist and "Israel"-adoring antifascists (the latter being a distinctly German aberration) within the party.
I spoke to Kilani in December of last year after the initial decision by DIE LINKE’s lower-level state arbitration body to expel him.
And though I am not surprised by the final outcome of this pathetic witch hunt, it pains me to see yet another Palestinian being betrayed by those who are supposed to stand in solidarity with him.
Genocidal Greens
Kilani’s ouster from DIE LINKE is not the only instance of left-wing German treachery in the context of Palestine in recent weeks.
From November 28-30, the Greens held their federal party convention in Hanover, to which, in yet another example of preemptive German obedience to "Israel", they invited as guest speaker no other than former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert.
In early November, the Brussels-based Hind Rajab Foundation filed a criminal complaint in Germany against Olmert for war crimes committed during "Israel’s" 2008-2009 military offensive on Gaza ahead of his public appearance at the Haaretz conference in Berlin, co-organised by none other than the Green party-affiliated Heinrich Böll Foundation.
As if this weren’t enough, Green Party delegates also voted against recognising a Palestinian state.
One should bear in mind that the Greens are the party of former Foreign Minister and current President of the United Nations General Assembly, Annalena Baerbock.
During her tenure as Germany’s top diplomat, she lied about having seen a non-existent Hamas rape video and justified "Israel’s" mass killing of civilians when she infamously said, “Civilian sites could lose their protected status.”
A left in tatters
Germany’s political left is in shambles, and that is bad news for Palestinian solidarity in a country where crackdowns on anti-genocide protests have been among the most vicious, the most violent, and the most lawless.
DIE LINKE is plagued by incessant political and personal infighting.
The populist Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance (BSW), which broke away from DIE LINKE early last year, is not above spewing anti-immigrant vitriol sanitised as “left conservatism.”
The Greens have forsaken pretty much every left-wing ideal from pacifism to Palestine and even climate justice, their traditional core competency.
Yes, there is MERA25, founded in 2021, and the only party worthy of note that has dared to campaign on a platform of Palestinian liberation.
But it is a fledgling outfit that is still trying to find its groove and appeal to voters outside of Berlin, home to Europe’s largest Palestinian community and the party’s only smidgen of a stronghold in Germany (in February’s federal elections, MERA25 won 0,0% of the votes).
In light of the unstoppable ascendency of the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD), already the largest opposition party in the Bundestag, the timing for the country’s political left to be in such a fragmented state could not have come at a worse time.
A German left in tatters, with substantial parts of it on the wrong side of history (yet again) when it comes to the Gaza genocide, is detrimental to developing international solidarity, once a hallmark of German leftism on both sides of the Iron Curtain.
Now, more than ever, Palestine remains what political activist Angela Davis has referred to as “a moral litmus test for the world.”
A test that Germany’s mainstream political left is failing miserably.
Timo Al-Farooq