Automakers warn cheap cars may exit US market
Foreign automakers warn that Trump tariffs and USMCA uncertainty could force affordable cars out of the US, raising prices and disrupting supply chains.
-
Undated photo of Nissan Motor employees assembling the company’s electric vehicle Leaf at the Oppama plant in suburban Tokyo (AFP)
Carmakers outside of the United States are warning that the future of affordable vehicles in the US is increasingly uncertain, as trade tensions and Washington's tariff policies threaten to dismantle existing supply chains.
Industry representatives told the Wall Street Journal that without a renewed or stable United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), several companies may be forced to withdraw their cheapest models from the US market.
Manufacturers such as Nissan, Hyundai, and Toyota currently dominate the affordable vehicle segment, particularly after US-based automakers shifted toward higher-margin SUVs and trucks. Vehicles like the Honda Civic and Toyota Corolla remain among the few accessible options for lower-income buyers, though their production depends heavily on cross-border supply chains.
Tariffs reshape North American supply chains
The reintroduction of aggressive tariff measures under US President Donald Trump has placed significant strain on these integrated manufacturing systems. A 25% tariff on non-US content in vehicles, previously exempt under USMCA, has increased production costs and disrupted long-standing industrial cooperation across North America.
While the Trump administration argues that such policies are necessary for national security and domestic industrial revival, automakers contend that the abrupt changes undermine economic viability. There are also ongoing discussions about restructuring or even abandoning the USMCA framework, adding further uncertainty.
The potential withdrawal of low-cost vehicles comes at a time when affordability is already a critical issue. The average price of a new car in the US is approaching $50,000, placing ownership out of reach for many consumers.
Entry-level models such as the Nissan Sentra, built in Mexico and starting at $22,600, and the Hyundai Venue, imported from South Korea at $20,550, represent some of the last remaining budget-friendly options.
According to Edmunds, eight of the ten cheapest new vehicles in the US are produced by foreign-based automakers, underscoring the structural reliance on international manufacturing.
Read more: US expands push for military production with automakers
Industry pushback and economic strain
Automakers argue that current tariff structures are eroding already thin profit margins on affordable vehicles. “US automakers cannot continue to produce affordable options for American consumers without the certainty and scale provided by a trilateral USMCA,” said Jennifer Safavian, president of Autos Drive America, a trade group for foreign automakers in the US, told WSJ.
Executives have been more direct in their criticism. Nissan Americas Chairman Christian Meunier stated to WSJ that tariffs have been “killing our affordable cars,” emphasizing that a stable trade agreement could mitigate losses.
Meanwhile, Toyota has reported mounting financial losses in North America since the tariffs took effect. Despite plans to invest up to $10 billion in US manufacturing, company officials remain cautious. “It’s hard to say, ‘let’s throw that $2- $3 billion down right now,’ until you get some sort of a settlement,” said US sales chief David Christ.
Uncertain future of USMCA
The future of USMCA remains unclear as negotiations continue. US officials have indicated that any revised agreement would include stricter rules on automotive content, particularly targeting components sourced from China.
At the same time, tensions with Canada and Mexico persist. US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer has suggested potential retaliatory measures against Canada, while Mexican officials have acknowledged that tariffs may remain part of any future deal.
Limited concessions, such as partial tariff reimbursements and conditional reductions on steel and aluminum, have done little to ease industry concerns, with companies arguing that these measures are insufficient and narrowly applied.