Attend to the message; it outweighs the messenger
Makram Khoury-Machool argues that the public intellectual’s task is not to compete for attention but to transform abundant information into rigorous, critical understanding—particularly for Palestinians seeking to reclaim their own narrative amid war, propaganda and intellectual dependency.
-
The decades after the crimes of the CleansOcide will require Palestinians to produce, order, and preserve knowledge about what has happened to them. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Fatima Attieh)
My person is of little consequence. I am not a purveyor of news from the field of combat, nor an accomplice in political clamour. I am neither politician nor protest organiser, neither party professional nor envoy of any regime or authority.
What concerns me is something at once quieter and, I believe, more enduring: the construction of an idea, the coining of a term where one is needed, and the ordering and conveyance of knowledge that may prove useful. For ours is not an age starved of information, but one increasingly starved of the means to order and understand it. This matters especially now, when human history at large - and the history of the Arab nation, the Levant and West Asia in particular - is being made before us with rare intensity.
What is said matters more than who says it, provided that what is said serves.
This is how I understand my calling as an academic and public intellectual. The academic who assumes a public role cannot remain confined to the lecture theatre or the refereed journal. Nor should knowledge become ornament, professional currency or a pulpit for partisan allegiance.
The task is to carry method from the narrow precinct of the discipline into the public square: to elucidate rather than indoctrinate, to take apart rather than inflame, and to help people understand not merely what is happening around them, but why it is happening, what forces animate it, and what its farther consequences may be.
The public intellectual does not deputise for the politician. He does not race the media for speed, nor solicit applause. His function is different. We stand, at our best, as a hinge between ordered knowledge and the public, placing instruments of understanding in people’s hands rather than locking them behind the walls of the institution.
This task becomes more urgent when truth is entangled with noise, tragedy with propaganda, and the tears of bereavement with the blood of martyrdom. It is of particular consequence in the age of the crimes of the CleansOcide,ʿirqbāda, by which I mean the conjunction of genocide and ethnic cleansing, in the Gaza Strip and across the broader region.
To say this is not to inflate the importance of the academic. Quite the opposite. The individual matters less precisely because the intellectual task matters more.
My own contribution to that task has been shaped by a many-branched academic life across cultures and continents, and by command of several languages: Arabic, Hebrew, English, alongside other European and African languages. It has also been shaped by being Palestinian: born along the axis of the Naksa of 1967, raised under occupation, schooled in Hebrew from childhood, and later transplanted to Britain and its academic citadel—gracious at times, oppressive at others.
For roughly a quarter of a century, students have paid substantial fees to be taught by me in British universities, beginning with Cambridge in 2003. Yet knowledge acquires a different responsibility when it leaves the university and enters the public realm. What has been accumulated within institutions should, where possible, be returned freely to the common good.
My Palestinian experience is not invoked as vanity of identity or place. The whole earth is our expanse; the lands of the Arabs are my homelands, and all Palestine is my country—from the Galilee of Jesus of Nazareth to the Gaza of Hashem. My birthplace is Jaffa, bride of the sea, once crowned with orange groves that have been slashed and burnt.
But biography is useful only insofar as it furnishes instruments of understanding.
To inhabit several languages and worlds is to acquire the possibility of reading political movement from more than one vantage point: to join geography and demography to political economy; to examine centres of power; to place narratives against one another; and to read a context simultaneously from within and without. In my case, that labour must serve first the tormented and abandoned land of Palestine and its people.
Having lived and worked among non-Arab scholars in the West, I have profound respect for rigorous scholarship and the scientific method. We should neither dismiss these achievements nor retreat into intellectual provincialism.
But openness is not submission.
I am not enchanted by khawajas, nor dazzled by those who step forward from abroad to seize our narrative at our expense. We may appreciate those who seek to understand our suffering. We may welcome solidarity. But there is something deeply disordered when the foreign interpreter is treated as inherently more authoritative than the people whose history, dispossession and struggle he interprets.
Let them speak. Let us listen. Let knowledge cross borders freely. But let us not surrender our story.
For otherwise the Arab risks entering a peculiar form of intellectual captivity: losing confidence in his own capacity to interpret the world and clinging to every imported formulation as though it were scripture.
This is not an argument for intellectual isolation. It is an argument for intellectual sovereignty.
Here lies the larger problem.
Information has become abundant. Books, studies, essays, archives, films and databases are available on a scale unimaginable to previous generations. Much of what we seek lies somewhere in a library or upon the networks.
Our difficulty is increasingly not access to information, but what we are capable of doing with it.
The true labour begins after the information has been obtained: distinguishing the true from the false and the misleading; breaking an argument into its constituent parts; identifying its assumptions; placing it within a wider historical and theoretical field; connecting one domain of knowledge with another; and from those fragments fashioning a coherent model of understanding.
This critical unmaking is indispensable if people are to grasp the motives of what is taking place around them, together with the meaning and scale of events.
Without it, history reaches us as a procession of alerts.
One headline displaces another. One atrocity follows the last. We consume fragments, repeat them, become angry or frightened by them, lose sleep over them—and yet possess no greater capacity to explain the structure producing them. Information then generates anxiety, sleeplessness and a fraying of the nerves rather than knowledge upon which thought or action can be built.
Raw information is shared freely. The operations that transform it into understanding are shared far less often.
Most people therefore consume fragments without converting them into an ordered understanding or into a capacity for use, comparison and critique.
This is where specialists, fine teachers and serious thinkers retain their importance. At their best, they possess a theoretical frame, disciplined method, an eye for patterns, knowledge of limits and exceptions, and the ability to connect one field to another.
Yet none of this belongs exclusively to those bearing academic titles.
Deep competence can be forged outside formal institutions. Method can be learned. Intellectual discipline can be cultivated. Indeed, the first professor who taught me at Oxford held only a first degree. The title is secondary; the labour is what matters.
Information, then, has grown cheap. Ordered understanding and the weaving of knowledge remain scarce, and therefore precious.
Specialisation helps greatly, but it is not the sole condition. The first condition is methodical labour: analysis, composition, comparison and critical unmaking.
That is what I understand the public intellectual to owe the public—not another voice competing for its share of the noise, but an attempt to make the noise intelligible.
And for Palestine, this distinction will become increasingly consequential.
The proliferation of social media has served Palestine in important ways over the past quarter-century, particularly since the Second Intifada began in September 2000. It has broken monopolies over images and testimony. It has allowed Palestinians to speak across borders, document what was once concealed, challenge official narratives and bring fragments of their lived reality before millions.
But circulation is not the same as knowledge.
The decades after the crimes of the CleansOcide will require more than the capacity to make Palestine visible. They will require Palestinians to produce, order and preserve knowledge about what has happened to them; to develop their own concepts; to interrogate the categories imposed upon them; to connect history, political economy, law, language, demography and power; and to ensure that others do not become the principal authors of Palestinian meaning.
Social media helped Palestine transmit its message.
The production of knowledge will help Palestinians retain possession of it.
That, more than the messenger, is what matters.
Makram Khoury-Machool