The Karak Church Massacre and the Geopolitical Plot!
The massacre targeting Arab Christians in Jordan reflects a broader effort to sow sectarian divisions, force displacement, and destabilize the Levant.
-
The October 23 massacre in Jordan is part of a broader campaign to displace Arab Christians, fuel sectarian strife, and undermine Jordan's national unity (Illustrated by Zeinab el-Hajj to Al Mayadeen English)
Twelve years ago, the Orthodox Cultural Society in the Jordanian capital, Amman, invited me to give a lecture entitled: Arab Christians and the events of the Levant! (That was during the assault on Christians in Iraq and just before the assault on Syria).
The hall of the Cultural Association was packed, and the attendees' feelings ranged from a need to understand what the lecturer (the author of these lines) was saying to a desire to prevent any harm from befalling Jordan, and specifically its Christian community. This was on March 27, 2024.
Because I am a son of the Arab nation (and I, as an independent academic and public intellectual, have political interventions in topics I choose), I see what is happening from a distance that sometimes allows me to be close, and sometimes far away, with a clear mind, using my cold scientific tools, and presenting my argument, according to the situation and the article.
Fifteen years ago, I agreed with an academic publishing house in London to write a volume in English about Arab media, intended for university teaching. I dedicated an entire chapter to the relationship between media and religion. With the unfolding of current events, I was required to revise and add material to the book, which led me to delve deeper into the topic of the relationship between politics, religion, and media.
During my research into the literature/sources, I noticed that most of those writing about Arab Christians are either Israelis, Zionist Jews, or Westerners (specifically Italians, French, and British). Some are academics, some are intelligence agents, and some belong to ethical groups genuinely concerned with preserving the Christian Arabs in the Holy Land.
This discussion, and what was happening in our Arab world at the time (the destruction of the national (not necessarily democratic state), motivated me to dedicate my time and energy to this topic. There is a need for Arab Christian researchers—in foreign languages, if possible, as well as in Arabic—to express themselves scientifically about Arab Christians today. This modest effort affirms a distinct identity and a desire to differentiate ourselves from the West and its sometimes strange and unfamiliar Western Christian beliefs, among other things.
I opened the lecture (March 27, 2024) by saying the following: In order to understand what is happening, I will break the subject down into different topics and put them in the spotlight, so that the features of things may become clear to us. Today's lecture is an attempt to deconstruct and understand the situation of Arab Christians in light of current events, which are taking place in the Arab world as a whole and in some countries in particular. It asks:
Current acts of violence (because they were subjected to them before, and for decades in the Nile Valley: Egypt and Sudan) against Arab Christians in the Levant:
- Does it represent sectarian strife or a conflict over identity and an attempt to draw the boundaries of citizenship?
- Are Christians in the Arab East facing a greater risk of extinction than ever before?
- Is there a relationship between national security and the status of Arab Christians?
I added:
Indeed, some acts of terrorism are indiscriminate… they are against everything and against any human being or archaeological site (and one should not so easily exclude any group of society). However, evidence indicates that certain acts of terrorism, such as kidnapping, rape, theft, destruction, displacement, and assassinations, specifically target Christians to displace them from their homeland, solely to fulfil the Israeli dream of transforming the conflict into one solely between Jews and Muslims, where Muslims are discredited, then defeated, and their resources confiscated… I added sarcastically, “only to be managed by the civilized, responsible, and moral Western capitalist world.”
In the geographical rectangle that extends from Iraq in the east to Mauritania in the west and from Syria in the north to Somalia and Sudan in the south, there is a demographic population with an Arab majority and a long Arab cultural history.
It is a mistake to ignore the existence of non-Arab Christian and Muslim minorities in our Arab world, such as the Dinka and Nuer Africans in South Sudan, as well as the Armenians, Syriacs, Turkmens, Circassians, Jews (Ashkenazim), and Berbers.
Arabism as an ethnicity predates religions – indeed, religions came before Arabism… Christianity was the first. The Arab East is the cradle of Christianity, and therefore its first adherents were in Palestine, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, and Egypt, despite the persecution of Jesus of Nazareth and Christianity by the Jews and Romans.
The Arabs embraced Christianity from its inception; indeed, they were part of it, as evidenced by what is stated in the Acts of the Apostles:
“We hear Cretans and Arabs speaking in our own tongues the great things of God.” (Acts 2-11).
Christianity spread among the Arabs in the Arabian Peninsula, but it spread more widely outside the peninsula, specifically in the Levant and Iraq, as in the case of the Ghassanids in southern Syria and the Lakhmids in southern Iraq, where the Arabs initially understood Christianity as a system of higher values and morals, and the general public among them did not interfere in theological and philosophical matters.
The Christian Arabs, or the Nasara – such as the Ghassanids who lived in southern Syria and the Lakhmids who lived in southern Iraq, the Syrian Desert, and western Iraq – did not have independent states, but they had a quasi-state or a system of self-rule under the Byzantines, for example, and they established communities in southern Arabia such as Najran and Yemen. (Al-Awdat, p. 39).
Other Arab tribes were Christian, but they were in religious conflict with the Byzantine and Persian empires. Important Arab cities arose on the borders between the Arabs and the surrounding states, forming what resembled kingdoms or city-states.
While the Arabs in the Levant were the environment in which Christianity arose, the Arabs also knew and embraced Christianity in Yemen and other tribes that embraced it in Bahrain, Mecca, and Taif.
Here it must be emphasized that Christianity 'spoke in Arabic before and after Islam, and that it is a whole in which the Arabic language was used, to varying degrees'. (p. 83)
Arab Christians established close relations with non-Arab Christians, such as the relations between the Ghassanids, the Copts, and the Abyssinians. There were also tensions between the two Christian kingdoms, the Ghassanids and the Lakhmids, over religious matters. In addition to the Ghassanids and the Lakhmids, there were Arab Christians in Najran, such as Banu Harith and Banu Ka'b. In addition to other Arab tribes who converted to Christianity, such as Taghlib, Bakr, Lakhm, and Judham (Al-Sirah al-Halabiyyah). Christianity was present in Rabi'ah (Ibn Qutaybah), except for Mudar, as Al-Jahiz mentioned.
The communities that inhabited Iraq and Greater Syria – Lebanon, Palestine, and Syria today – were overwhelmingly Arabs and Arameans, Christians…The Ghassanid Emirate was established in Syria…and the Republic of Petra in Jordan before the fifth century, where the Aramaic and Arabic languages were dominant alongside Greek and Persian.
Six centuries later, Islam emerged and took shape…and the Arabic language, the language of the Arabs before and after Christianity and before the Quran, and the language of the non-Christian Arabs who later became Muslims. The Quran mentions previous religions and events…and the revelation of the Quran in Arabic:
“And We did not send any messenger except [speaking] in the language of his people to clarify [the message] for them. Then Allah misguides whom He wills and guides whom He wills. And He is the Exalted in Might, the Wise.” (Surat Ibrahim, verse 4.
So how is it linked to the massacre in al-Karak on 23.10.2026?
The brutal terrorist crime committed by terrorists who were deliberately and premeditatedly sent to the St. George Church (Al-Khader Church) of the Greek Orthodox in the town of Hamoud in the Karak Governorate, during a funeral on Friday, October 23, 2026, turned into a massacre in which seven Jordanian martyrs were killed, and dozens were injured (no final count was published). It was a premeditated operation and not a lone wolf crime.
As experts on extremism, radicalism, and terrorism, we don't need a "source" to provide "information" confirming the involvement of the intelligence services of a neighbouring state (or more) in this brutal attack targeting Jordan as a whole. Even if this source agrees with our assessment, they won't make it public to avoid a diplomatic crisis!
This crime, although it appeared to be a single incident, was prepared for months because it required professional training and armament capable of a relatively long operation, not just a quick shooting like assassinations; lengthy and deliberate planning; prior intelligence; and coordination between several aspects and execution.
It is true that the massacre directly targeted Christian Arab mourners, but it is broader than that and falls within the framework of the geopolitical scheme that aims to empty the Levant of its original Christian Arab component, so that the criminal Netanyahu can portray the conflict as religious between “civilized Judaism” and “backward and violent Islam.”
The massacre is part of a project aimed at destabilizing Jordan, as happened previously in Karak in 2016 when ISIS claimed responsibility for an attack there.
Among the unstated objectives:
- Undermining personal and societal security in Jordan.
- An attempt to sow sectarian strife in a society where Christian and Muslim Arabs have coexisted for centuries, and for decades under Hashemite guardianship.
- Damaging Jordan’s image and reputation as a safe place for Christians so that Netanyahu can make claims that “the problem is not only with us where Christians are being targeted, but we live in a challenging region: look at Jordan, we are not alone.”
- Harming tourism and Jordan's economy.
- Targeting Christians in Jordan (less than 3% of the population.
- Creating panic to encourage the emigration of Christians or to create tension, a pattern known in previous extremist attacks in the region.
- An attempt to divert attention from the crimes of genocide (genocide and ethnic cleansing) in Palestine.
- Undermining the Hashemite custodianship and national unity.
Just as happened in Iraq and Syria in the last two decades, with the killing and displacement of Christians according to a broader plan, the same applies to Jordan today. The massacre in Jordan is part of the broader schemes of land-grabbing settlement in the Hebron Governorate.
A heinous crime of this kind could not have been committed without being part of a “Zionist-ISIS” project or a broader, specific external directive.
Makram Khoury-Machool