Al Mayadeen English

  • Ar
  • Es
  • x
Al Mayadeen English

Slogan

  • News
    • Politics
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Arts&Culture
    • Health
    • Miscellaneous
    • Technology
    • Environment
  • Articles
    • Opinion
    • Analysis
    • Blog
    • Features
  • Videos
    • NewsFeed
    • Video Features
    • Explainers
    • TV
    • Digital Series
  • Infographs
  • In Pictures
  • • LIVE
News
  • Politics
  • Economy
  • Sports
  • Arts&Culture
  • Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Technology
  • Environment
Articles
  • Opinion
  • Analysis
  • Blog
  • Features
Videos
  • NewsFeed
  • Video Features
  • Explainers
  • TV
  • Digital Series
Infographs
In Pictures
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • Asia-Pacific
  • Europe
  • Latin America
  • MENA
  • Palestine
  • US & Canada
BREAKING
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps: Any violation of Iranian airspace by any state or aggressor force will be met with a powerful and decisive response from our fighters
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps: The Islamic Republic of Iran’s airspace is a red line for the country’s Armed Forces
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps: Following violations of Iranian airspace by MQ-1 and MQ-9 drones, the Aerospace Force targeted the two aforementioned sites in Bahrain
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps: US military equipment and the naval vessels it protects have sustained heavy losses at sea and in the air
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps: Since dawn today, the US military’s costly escort and air-cover operations have failed to achieve their objectives
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps: The strikes came in response to the continued aggression and violation of the Islamic Republic of Iran’s airspace
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps: Two Patriot air-defense radars at the Riffa and Awali bases in Bahrain were targeted with missile and drone fire
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps news agency: Contrary to the US military’s denial, an F-16 fighter jet transmitted the 7700 emergency code
Iran: Islamic Revolution Guard Corps news agency: US Central Command’s denial does not erase the heavy losses sustained by the US military
Bahrain: Interior Ministry: An Iranian attack targeted a “civilian industrial facility,” and civil defense teams are working to contain the fire

The Empire strikes back… at Jameela Jamil!

  • Nu’man Abd al-Wahid Nu’man Abd al-Wahid
  • Source: Al Mayadeen English
  • 28 Aug 2026 15:26
12 Min Read

Nu’man Abd al-Wahid challenges the backlash against Jameela Jamil’s criticism of Britain’s colonial past.

  • x
  • The Empire strikes back….at Jameela Jamil!
    Why Britain’s colonial legacy remains so difficult to confront (AI-generated for Al Mayadeen English)

The actress and social media influencer Jameela Jamil recently aroused the wrath of British Empire nostalgists and apologists following her appearance on an alternative media podcast. Jameela riled the apologists for two reasons. Firstly, for claiming that Brexit “paved the way” for President Donald Trump’s electoral successes and secondly for stating that “British people are truly the most evil people in history” and substantiated this latter opinion by referring to the academic findings of two scholars who concluded that India (including Pakistan and Bangladesh) is owed £43 trillion in reparations for the British imperialist plundering of the country over a period of almost 200 years. “We colonised the world!” she exclaimed. Needless to say, Jameela’s millions of social media followers strongly imply her comments have a real-world impact. Britain’s leading venerable and oldest right-wing rag, the Spectator Magazine, edited by neo-con former Conservative politician Michael Gove, was clearly far from impressed and predictably rose to the occasion with all guns blazing with a three-pronged attack on Jameela on its website within a space of no less than twenty-four hours. The following unpacks each of the attacks and exposes the spectacular shortcomings of each assault.

The first salvo was launched on the evening of 22nd July at approximately 8:13 pm, delivered by the Royal family biographer and current Spectator books editor, Alexander Larman. He demeans, pathologises, and categorises her comments as “batshit crazy utterances." In other words, she’s insane, therefore irrational. By playing the man, instead of the ball, Larman simply listed moments in her personal life when she was supposedly contradicting herself. Apparently, this is all the evidence one requires to rebuke Jameela. Rather than dealing with the issues Jameela addresses – Brexit and reparations – he simply opines that her comments were to ‘garner attention’ and more so ‘emotive’ with spurious factual basis. Larman clearly doesn’t feel the need to prove how Jameela is wrong because he has already personally pathologised her as ‘crazy’ – and at the end of the day who reasons with crazy people besides the professionally qualified. In Larman’s world, dedicating your life to writing hefty books about pampered imperialists and ornamental aristocrats is of course not an insane pastime but reiterating the call for global retributive financial justice warrants one being called “crazy”.

The next salvo was delivered the following morning by none other than an Oxford University History Professor, Lawrence Goodman, whose hit piece was posted at approximately 7:18 am. Being a Professor, Goodman rightly identifies that the £43 trillion reparations figure first came to public attention through the works of the Indian Marxist economist, Professor Usta Patnaik. He takes issue with this sum not by questioning the figures but simply quoting another Indian professor who claims that old Blighty never made a penny out of plundering and pillaging India for almost 200 years. Goodman’s strategy is the oldest in the imperial playbook – pitting one Indian against another. During almost 200 years of British colonial rule, Britain visited wave upon wave of famines, taking the lives of tens of millions of Indians, but this means nothing to Goodman because he’s majestically found an Indian lickspittle who also wants to absolve the British Empire of any wrongdoing.

Goodman proceeds to take credit for Indian and Pakistani independence and their respective status as democratic countries. For those of us who’ve read some Indian political history, independence was ‘granted’ largely because Britain no longer had the power to oppress hundreds of millions of Indians after it was severely weakened in the wake of World War Two. Alien to Goodman is also the fact that Britain played Muslims off Hindus; it played divide and rule to consolidate its conquest of India, especially after the 1857 Great Indian uprising, which saw Hindus and Muslims unite against the British occupation. The Indian politician Shashi Tharoor claims that this unity “alarmed the British." The main reason we have an India and Pakistan today is that the British Empire sowed the seeds of division between the two main religious groups after 1857 and not because, as he implies, due to any British enlightened endowment.

Goodman then trumpets the British contribution to Indian culture and to the study of India itself without mentioning that, according to an Indian academic, the British left India in 1947 with a literacy rate of no more than 15%. From these stale attempts at refuting Jameela’s argument, he turns to patronising Jameela. He lets it be known that it’s beyond his comprehension that a person raised in relative comfort in London who ‘benefited’ from a British education should then turn around and speak truths about the British Empire. For Goodman, the notion that Jameela shows moral solidarity with the victims of the British Empire clearly shows a lack of “self-awareness”. He doesn’t consider her to be in possession of a moral conscience but as someone who’s bewilderingly gone astray. The profound question Professor Goodman seems to be asking is why inconvenience yourself with a global retributive campaign over long-dead ‘coolies’ (as imperialists used to refer to Indians) when instead you could doggedly accumulate personal wealth? Or as he phrases it, “she seems to have enjoyed the best things on offer. Yet still she criticises.” By expressing this bafflement, the professor may be expressing his own profound moral bankruptcy.

The final salvo was fired by the former editor of the right-wing Spiked-Online journal, Brendan O’Neill, later in the day at approximately 2:22 pm. Spiked-Online was formed by the failed revolutionaries of the fringe British Revolutionary Communist Party (RCP). (O’Neill is one of a number of high-profile acolytes of the main ideological guru of the RCP, Professor Frank Furedi, who have now all switched sides to champion Empire and genocide). O’Neill denounces her from two directions. Firstly, he claims Jameela is simply an out-of-touch celebrity. That is out of touch with the people he implies he represents, the British working class. O’Neill’s emotional rant is that Jameela dwells among the “pampered enclaves” and “coddled classes” who, like her, are beholden to “luxury beliefs,” and for good measure argues that her ‘gaudy anti-colonialism’ is a ‘dusty relic’ from the BLM [Black Lives Matter] years. These people have had their day and, according to O’Neill, are now being swept aside by the “patriots of the working class” who are “sensible” because the idea that Britain may owe trillions in reparations is part of an “elite culture of shame” peddled by a “self-loather” who is lording it over “working class communities." In O’Neill’s topsy-turvy worldview, it is Jameela who is oppressing the British working class with her belief system (i.e., “luxury beliefs”). And lo and behold, the working class is now striding forth against the champions of famished ghosts of millions of starved Indians.

Related News

Psywar no more? 77th Brigade’s sudden death

How Sir David Bell’s review turned anger at 'Israel' into an antisemitism crisis in schools

O’Neill then castigates Jameela as anti-patriotic and deploys a George Orwell observation about the English intelligentsia to bolster his diatribe: “England is perhaps the only great country whose intellectuals are ashamed of their own nationality." Let’s put aside that Jameela may not claim to be an intellectual, but interestingly, in Orwell’s Road to Wigan Pier, Orwell clearly and brutally laid out his view of the British Empire and dubbed it an “evil despotism”. It is totally lost on O’Neill that Orwell may have had much sympathy with Jameela’s sentiments. Furthermore, in an essay, Not Counting Ni**ers, Orwell has some interesting observations about the British working class. This essay, written just before the outbreak of the European inter-white-supremacist war in September 1939 (it didn’t become a united “World War” until December 1941, more than two years later), argued that the British working class represents ‘overwhelmingly’ the Indians and other peoples living under the boot of the British Empire,

“What we always forget is that the over­whelming bulk of the British proletariat does not live in Britain, but in Asia and Africa. It is not in Hitler’s power, for instance, to make a penny an hour a normal industrial wage; it is perfectly normal in India, and we are at great pains to keep it so. One gets some idea of the real relationship of England and India when one reflects that the per capita annual income in England is something over £80, and in India about £7. It is quite common for an Indian coolie’s leg to be thinner than the average Englishman’s arm. And there is nothing racial in this, for well-fed members of the same races are of normal physique; it is due to simple starvation. This is the system which we all live on…”

For Orwell, the British Empire could afford a relatively high standard of living for its domestic population because it was, inter alia, starving Indians on the other side of the world. O’Neill’s selective use of Orwell simply exposes his own ignorance of what Orwell stood for.  

So there we have it. The Spectator’s three-pronged approach amounted to a Royal biographer questioning Jameela’s sanity, followed by an Oxbridge professor pitting one Indian against another, and finally a failed ‘Revolutionary Communist’ heroically denouncing her for the supposed socio-cultural class she belongs to. None address the substance behind her statements.

Of course, others couldn’t resist in the metaphorical internet lynching of Jameela. One example will suffice. Samuel Rubenstein, a History academic, took the opportunity to denounce her in the UnHerd online magazine. Unlike O’Neill, Rubenstein made a tokenistic attempt to engage with her arguments but not before claiming that Jameela’s arguments are “hackneyed”. He seems perplexed that Jameela would incredulously establish a connection between Brexit and Trump, even though the latter was clearly inspired by the 2016 Brexit campaign led by the British politician Nigel Farage. Rubenstein then argues that Germans, Japanese, and Hutus are more evil than the British. More so, it was the British who ‘stood’ up to the Nazis. Obviously, the notion that the British ‘stood up’ against the Nazis is nothing other than standard post-World War Two British state propaganda claptrap. The European aspect of the war against the German Nazis, led by Adolf Hitler, officially began in September 1939, and when the real fighting actually commenced in continental Europe on 10th May 1940, the British Army (BEF) immediately deserted its allies, the French and Belgians, and simply fled to Dunkirk to cross the English Channel back to England. Having heroically stabbed their fellow European white supremacist allies in the back for most of May 1940, the BEF was back in England by the end of the first week of June 1940. This successful desertion was greatly assisted by Hitler, who held back his army on the 24th of May from advancing on Dunkirk. The contested reason behind Hitler stalling his army is one that historians like Rubenstein inevitably find difficulty to even acknowledge, which is that Hitler was an admirer of the British Empire. Hitler is on record as saying that what India was to Britain, Russia shall be to Germany. In other words, Hitler intended to loot and pillage Russia in the same manner that Britain had rapaciously helped itself to the resources of India for almost 200 years. In Hitler’s vision, the British Empire was literally the blueprint for the German Third Reich. After the scurry at Dunkirk, the British Army didn’t engage with the “main body of German” forces for the next four years, whereupon they courageously returned on the shoulders of American troops. Ultimately, it was Russia – the then Soviet Union – which actually engaged and stood up to over 90% of the Nazi land forces. It was the Soviet Union that ‘stood’ up to the Nazis. Rubenstein’s historical illiteracy is no match for Jameela’s truth about Brexit and reparations.

Naturally, the question of whether the average Briton should be held morally and financially culpable for the actions of its Empire is perfectly legitimate, but that is not the question the imperialist nostalgists of the Spectator magazine and elsewhere address. And before attacking Jameela or anyone else who questions the nature of the British Empire, apologists should always ponder what Orwell said about Hitler when war broke out in Europe in 1939:

“[Hitler] is only the ghost of our own past rising against us. He stands for the extenuation and perpetuation of our own methods…”

The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect Al Mayadeen’s editorial stance.
  • Britain
  • India
  • British Empire
  • United Kingdom
  • Ukraine
Nu’man Abd al-Wahid

Nu’man Abd al-Wahid

Author of “Debunking the Myth of America’s Poodle”.

Most Read

All
Why Washington may attack Iran again

Why Washington may attack Iran again

  • Analysis
  • 15 Nov 2026
The unit’s April reorganisation reinforces how its founding raison d’etre was laying the foundations, and shaping the online theatre, for future conflict with Moscow. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab el-Hajj)

Psywar no more? 77th Brigade’s sudden death

  • Analysis
  • 10 Nov 2026
Glasgow’s students stand with Palestine. Why doesn’t the university’s leadership?

Glasgow’s students stand with Palestine. Why doesn’t the university’s leadership?

  • Politics
  • 13 Nov 2026
This Gate will be defended by those who understand that sovereignty is not a gift from above, but a covenant: a covenant of the head laid low at the threshold…(Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

The gate to a global mosaic

  • Opinion
  • 16 Nov 2026

Coverage

All
Israeli Elections 2026: The Politics of Evil

More from this writer

All
It’s time there was a robust effort to end this unspoken historical consensus, this ‘memory-holing’. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

The unspoken historical consensus that unites British pro-Palestinians and pro-Zionists

After the failure of Trump’s MAGA, any future ‘America First’ strategy must inevitably acknowledge and contend with the British imperialist roots of all the ‘forever wars’ in West Asia. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Batoul Chamas)

The United States’s only viable ‘off-ramp’ in West Asia is a rejection of British imperialist strategy

Trump, Chamberlain, and decolonizing the Munich Agreement

Trump, Chamberlain, and decolonizing the Munich Agreement

Bannon seeking deliverance by indulging in the World War One “side-show” myths of the Republic’s former imperial master certainly will not augur well for the “America First” movement. (Al Mayadeen English; Illustrated by Zeinab el-Hajj)

Steve Bannon’s Lawrence of Arabia 'side-show' analogy is a dud

Al Mayadeen English

Al Mayadeen is an Arab Independent Media Satellite Channel.

All Rights Reserved

  • x
  • Privacy Policy
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Authors
Android
iOS